We really enjoyed our cruise. Here are some random thoughts:
Itinerary: Iceland was the main draw and it did not disappoint! Spectacular and very cold! Many pax were unprepared for the weather. Took ship excursions in all 3 ports and were very pleased. The Norwegian ports of Olden and Alesund were just ok. Not a whole lot to do. I guess by that time we had seen enough fjords, waterfalls, and glaciers. The Orkney Islands in Scotland was a fascinating excursion and one can never get enough of Edinburgh IMHO. 2 days at sea was just right.
Stateroom - Our midship Oceanview with Balcony on Deck 10 was a perfect location. Quiet. close but not too close to elevators and no motion. We requested and received a mattress topper. Enough storage, a smallish loveseat, a surprisingly large shower and separate toilet (both with sliding doors) a new easy to operate safe and a very cold fridge! Only complaint was no nightstand on one side of the bed and terrible lighting. They NEED to put reading lights by the bed.
Entertainment: The production shows were just average but the guest entertainers were stupendous! Probably the best guitarist - from Chile - I have ever seen, a hilarious juggler, a non-boring illusionist and his contortionist wife. WOW! There was the usual complement of game shows - pretty fun. I just could not stand the main cruise staff guy - his assistants were much better.
Bars - Great assortment of bars and the happiest and friendliest bartenders ever! Fast service but since the ship only had 1300 PAX service and seating was never an issue.
Specialty Dining - Hands down, Cagney's was the best. We were very disappointed in Le Bistro. Mediocre food. My filet of sole was full of bones. The French Onion soup just had a sprinkling of Parmesan on top. No lamb chops. The Chocolate dessert with the long name was just a HoHo in disguise. La Cucina was ok. We just weren't that hungry that night - weren't feeling too well near the end of the cruise.
Buffet - I am not ashamed to admit that I loved the buffet - for all the meals. Lots of variety. Unexpected delights like a huge bowl of cashews, gravlax, the best and ripest cantaloupe I have had on a cruise.
Ginza - appetizers excellent, entrees meh. (ate here twice).
I will add more in the upcoming days. Meanwhile happy to answer any questions!