Half Moon Cay vs Little Stirrup Cay

[curious_st]

I am considering booking on the Fascination this fall. Any thoughts on these 2 private islands?

[CruiserBruce]

There are tons of threads just down this board. HMC is commonly rated the best private island out there. Do you have specific questions?

[Typhoon1]

Porthole magazine rates HMC an eleven on a scale from one to ten.

[marshhawk]

We loved our time at HMC, and are trying LSC this fall. I love the beach, I don't have to have more than sand and water to have fun. HMC is larger, LSC is only a mile long. HMC offers horse back riding. LSC has very few activities. I guess if you are a water baby, start out with LSC and then take another cruise to HMC, to find paradise later-one thing though, if the surf is bad, you will not tender to either island.

[kamari]

I have been to both. I absolutely love Coco Cay