Is Freedom Getting American Table?

[winddawn]

Does anyone know if Freedom will be getting the American Table and American Feast menus after the upgrades?

 

Thanks!

[Gingee]

What is that?

[Sarah@Sea]

No clue, but I can let you know after my cruise in May, just booked her!

[maighdeanmhara]

Hope not. . .

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Forums

[christmas]

Per John Heald the Carnival Freedom will not receive the new menus during dry dock.

[Pellaz]

Per John Heald the Carnival Freedom will not receive the new menus during dry dock.

 

Moreover, unless something changed recently I think the entire new-menu rollout has been suspended indefinitely....which basically means SOMEBODY's market-research didn't quite measure up to reality. :eek:

[christmas]

Moreover, unless something changed recently I think the entire new-menu rollout has been suspended indefinitely....which basically means SOMEBODY's market-research didn't quite measure up to reality. :eek:

 

Good, I hated the new menu on my last cruise!

[welldone60]

I think it's going to be a work in progress on the ships that have it. Per JH last week they are adding things to it and dropping some items. He did say there are no plans to put it on more ships at this time.

[lucigo]

Without knowing too much about what actually is on the menu, but having heard a lot about what is NOT on the menu, I'm not looking forward to it. But I think their biggest mistake is the naming of it. I cruise to try new things and get a "worldly" experience. American Table/Feast sounds like something you would get at Shoneys, Ryans, or Applebees. Not my idea of cruise food.

[winddawn]

Thanks for sharing. Here are some examples of the (controversial) American Table menu. I plan to cruise on Freedom later this year with some friends who are new to cruising and want to be able to let them know what to expect. It sounds like it might still be up in the air.

 

http://zydecocruiser.net/CarnivalInspiration2/Menus/index.html

[TPFKAH]

Thanks for sharing. Here are some examples of the (controversial) American Table menu. I plan to cruise on Freedom later this year with some friends who are new to cruising and want to be able to let them know what to expect. It sounds like it might still be up in the air.

 

http://zydecocruiser.net/CarnivalInspiration2/Menus/index.html

 

That page just asked me for a "contribution".

[winddawn]

That page just asked me for a "contribution".

Lol. That's Zydecocruiser's page. Contributions not required. He's on this board frequently although I don't think I've seen his posts lately. I don't know him, but he does a great job of uploading lots of pictures and is a wealth of Carnival information.

[TPFKAH]

Lol. That's Zydecocruiser's page. Contributions not required. He's on this board frequently although I don't think I've seen his posts lately. I don't know him, but he does a great job of uploading lots of pictures and is a wealth of Carnival information.

 

I don't even see him listed as a member, but to me that's advertising.

[winddawn]

I don't even see him listed as a member, but to me that's advertising.

I think he uses Sargent_Schultz as a screen name. Here is one of his reviews where you can make the connection.

 

http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=1925746&highlight=schultz

Edited April 16, 2014 by winddawn

[TPFKAH]

I think he uses Sargent_Schultz as a screen name. Here is one of his reviews where you can make the connection.

 

http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=1925746&highlight=schultz

 

He's not listed as a member either. I guess he has left us.

[Sparky2]

He's not listed as a member either. I guess he has left us.

 

You may be right. Haven't seen any postings from him recently. Too bad.

[MEOWSMURPHY]

Does anyone know what ships currently have the new menus? I'd like to steer clear of them :D

[LKYGSR]

Per John Heald the Carnival Freedom will not receive the new menus during dry dock.

 

 

Hooray !:)

[LeisaH3067]

Does anyone know what ships currently have the new menus? I'd like to steer clear of them :D

 

 

I can say the Liberty has it...did not like it at all :(

[nealstuber]

Moreover, unless something changed recently I think the entire new-menu rollout has been suspended indefinitely....which basically means SOMEBODY's market-research didn't quite measure up to reality. :eek:

 

 

Probably the same rocket scientist behind the playlist productions! Hope these are also on hold.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Forums mobile app

[MEOWSMURPHY]

I can say the Liberty has it...did not like it at all :(

 

Thanks...we sailed Liberty in October so I'm good to steer clear of that one..:D

[wanderingjew]

i miss him

Edited April 19, 2014 by wanderingjew

[jimbo5544]

Probably the same rocket scientist behind the playlist productions! Hope these are also on hold.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Forums mobile app

 

 

Can't say as I have not experienced it, but I applaud them for trying something new.

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Forums mobile app

[EZ4]

That page just asked me for a "contribution".

 

$5 is popular.

[MissKIA]

Probably the same rocket scientist behind the playlist productions! Hope these are also on hold.

 

Well Freedom IS getting new playlist shows so it doesn't look like it. They are brand new ones though so hopefully they are new and improved.