RCL vs NCL During the Winter - NYC

[robbykapnj]

Hi,

 

We might book either the Breakaway (or Anthem again) this week. Would appreciate anyone's opinion on both ships for the holiday season (or preferences in general for a winter sailing). I've read about hesitation regarding the Breakaway for a 7 night sailing during the winter. Last year we did a 10 night on Anthem and loved it. We are concerned about things to do indoors for at least half of the cruise being cold weather.

 

In particular:

-Daytime comparison (lack of indoor space on the Breakaway)?

-Nighttime entertainment comparison?

-Is there a guest entertainer on the winter 7 night cruises?

-Guest comparison during holiday season? Had a lot of tri-state area on Anthem, how about Breakaway?

-Grown low to mid-20's children - any preference? People around their age on both for the holiday sailings?

-Included food option comparison?

-If per day pricing was equal, what would you choose? We are hesitant to break from our favorite ship/cruise line with Royal but are open minded.

-What are the chances we can dock at the private island during the winter / holiday sailing?

 

Thanks!

[Clarea]

Running threads:

 

https://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=2549608

https://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=2549462

[robbykapnj]

Thanks!

[Clarea]

Thanks!

You're welcome.