I called yesterday to upgrade our drinks and the agent asked if "we both wanted to upgrade". So lots of inconsistent results. We did both want to so I don't know what would have happened if I had only asked for one.
Today I noticed that beef short ribs had been added to one of the night's menu on our upcoming Silhouette cruise as well as the prime rib on a different night. Things are looking up!
Our daughter just returned from a cruise on Reflection and they had changed the Short Ribs to Beef Bourguignon at the concierge lunch. We go in a few weeks and I love the short ribs too, so disappointed. She said the Bourguignon was good. Anyone have a current menu? I would like to see what else is offered and she doesn't remember..
And I'm not seeing short ribs on any of the MDR menus...
The only way I have heard of is to do a mock booking on Celebrity's site. You'll have to look at every category cabin. I did our 3/27 Silhouette sailing this way and found 563 available cabins on 1/22 and it was down to 306 available on 2/20. So sales are pretty strong.