I agree with most of your post. Although, we do get a larger cabin, that is our choice. We bring one bottle of wine each. We use OBC, pay the crew appreciation fee and get discounted wi-fi as Elites and rarely spend beyond our budget, except for special excursions that appeal to us. We have enjoyed Alfredo's which is more than just pizza. However, our next cruise is on the Emerald, so no Alfredo's and will definitely not pay for it on future cruises. We have done specialty dining on previous cruises, so no need to go again. MDR is excellent. On our last cruise (Caribbean Princess), the reserved section was mostly empty and five minutes before showtime, they sent the SRO cruisers to that section. We don't need special desserts and I can practice TaiChi in my cabin, so no interest in fitness classes. My fear is that they will slowly charge or increase charges for things we do enjoy: bingo, trivia, use of the gym or who knows what!