Cruise Ship Captain Strands Passengers in Maine

[Gail & Marty sailing away]

It happens ...

[BOSN]

* UPDATED ARTICLE - PORTLAND PRESS HERALD 30 SEPT 2011 *

** Mega Berth is advertised as 35 feet along the pier, BUT IT IS ONLY 29 FEET. Article states IT WAS NOT DREDGED...**

 

September 30

Megaberth too shallow for big ships?

 

On Tuesday, a cruise ship left the pier early to avoid low tide, and a city official says more dredging is needed.

 

By J. Hemmerdinger jhemmerdinger@pressherald.com

Staff Writer

 

PORTLAND - Late last year, a committee of city and Portland Harbor officials sent a letter to then-Gov. John Baldacci recommending dredging along the eastern end of Portland's "megaberth," which was under construction.

 

click image to enlarge

 

The cruise ship MV Aurora docks at the Ocean Gateway megaberth Thursday. On Tuesday, a ship was forced to leave the pier several hours early due to an extreme low tide. Gregory Rec/Staff Photographer

Select images available for purchase in the

Maine Today Photo Store

 

 

But Ocean Gateway Pier II, which opened Sept. 10, was not dredged, and on Tuesday a cruise ship's captain left the berth early to avoid shallow water.

The early departure exposed a limitation of the pier, which has been billed by the city as a deep-water berth. But city officials said it doesn't indicate a design flaw in the berth, and noted that conditions like those on Tuesday are rare.

Maine Port Authority Executive Director John Henshaw, who was on the committee, said his group recommended that the water depth at the pier be at least 35 feet, the same depth as the shipping channel.

"To make it as usable as possible, having a ... depth of 35 feet would have been desirable," he said.

Portland Mayor Nicholas Mavodones agreed that dredging would improve the berth. "There is a need, down the road, to do additional dredging," he said. "But there is no firm time line or budget put together."

Mavodones said initial plans called for the berth to be above a 60-foot-deep hole where Bath Iron Works had a dry dock. The plan was altered during construction, and the berth was extended east, over the shallow water, to accommodate larger ships.

On Tuesday, the 951-foot Caribbean Princess shoved off the megaberth at about 2:30 p.m., even though it wasn't leaving the harbor until 6 p.m., and rode out an astronomical low tide in deeper water. Some passengers who had left the ship were not notified and were later ferried from shore to the ship.

Mavodones, who manages operations for Casco Bay Lines, said, "It won't (happen) frequently."

Mark Klopp, a harbor pilot who guides large ships into and out of the harbor, said the 2:30 p.m. pier departure of the Caribbean Princess was planned well in advance. He said most big ships plan their schedules around tides.

"It was not a problem for that ship, being at that berth," he said, noting that ships are required to have at least one foot of water under their keel at a pier. "There are other ports where they have to watch the tides. We are not alone. Portland isn't like a sore thumb."

Portland's spokeswoman, Nicole Clegg, said the water on the east end of the berth -- the shallowest part -- is 30.1 feet deep at the average low-water mark. But Klopp said ships use a different figure, called the "controlling depth," which is 29.1 feet at the same point.

Because of gravity from the moon and planets, the water fell 1.37 feet below average at 5:24 p.m. Tuesday, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Therefore, the depth at the pier could theoretically have been 27.73 feet.

The Caribbean Princess draws 27 feet, meaning the bottom of the ship might have had just 8.8 inches of clearance at low tide. Other cruise ships visiting Portland this fall draw 26 to 29 feet.

According to NOAA predictions, water levels in Portland Harbor are expected to drop 1 foot or more below the average low-water mark on 57 days in 2011.

The water level will drop below average again Sunday, when the Jewel of the Seas, which draws 28 feet, is scheduled to be at the megaberth from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. The tide will not be at its lowest until 10 p.m.

Seven other ships are scheduled to use the berth before the season ends Oct. 23, but none of those visits will coincide with the lowest tides.

Other factors, like offshore winds, can make sea level fall several inches more than predicted, said Robert Eldridge White Jr., publisher of the Eldridge Tide and Pilot Book.

A ship's position at the pier is another factor. A ship with a deep stern, tied with the stern to the east, could have less clearance, said Clegg.

Klopp said captains decide how to dock based on the location of their passenger doors.

Accounts of the circumstances of Tuesday's early pier departure by the Caribbean Princess differ.

Klopp said the ship was scheduled "months in advance" to leave the berth at 2:30 p.m.

"This is common," he said. "We plan around (the tides)."

And Mavodones, who met the ship's captain earlier Tuesday, thought the crew had told passengers of the change before they disembarked.

But a Princess Cruises spokeswoman called the early pier departure unplanned.

"We weren't able to communicate this change to those passengers who were ashore at the time," said Karen Candy, manager of media relations. "We reacted to the tidal conditions at the time."

Candy noted that the cruise line transferred passengers safely from Portland to the ship, which was then in the harbor, using tenders. The ship left Portland Harbor at its scheduled time.

"This unusual weather condition will in no way impact our decision to continue to bring passengers to Portland," she said.

[excitedcruzr]

Just a quote from the subtitle. That's how I read it. But I do agree, it is not like the San Juan situation.

 

Cruise ship departs 'megaberth' early in response to astronomical low tide

 

The Caribbean Princess' captain strands a number of passengers on shore.

 

By Dennis Hoey dhoey@mainetoday.com

Staff Writer

 

Can you explain the San Juan situation, please?

[Tucker in Texas]

Can you explain the San Juan situation, please?

 

Because of Hurricane Irene, a Royal Caribbean and a Carnival ship had to leave port a few hours early on embarkation day as the port was closed down around 6:00 p.m. Carnival took care of those left ashore. Royal Caribbean, not exactly. They took care of those that bought air through them but that was about it.

 

Those that had passports could go to the first port (Aruba) and catch the ship. Those that didn't were out of luck. Always have a passport even if it is closed loop and you can get by with a birth certificate/photo ID.

 

Tucker in Texas

[welldone60]

Can you explain the San Juan situation, please?

A few weeks back, a storm was heading for San Juan. The port athourity ordered the cruise ships to depart as they were closing the port. Carnival & RCCL ships left ahead of the scheduled departure time and left 100's of people who had not boarded yet, some who were on late flights and had not arrived in PR. The cruise lines had no choice as you do not want a cruise ship tied to a dock in high winds.

[CanWeGoYet?]

tiny derail: I saw the match up of who is who for Dark Shadows - perfect casting Dr. Julia Hoffman, Angelique should have been Carolyn Stoddard, need someone entirely different for Angelique, Victoria Winters a blond? No way!

 

end derail:

 

Even though the captain did absolutely the right thing in heading out to deeper water - had I seen the cruise ship pull away before I was on it, I would have had a flippin conniption fit.