Which snorkeling is better in Belize?

[Robegraham]

Sergeant's Caye Snorkeling Adventure

or

the "Ocean Runner" to Water Caye

[HUNKY]

I imagine snorkeling at both locations is fantastic! Belize has one of the best barrier reefs in the world.

 

I chose the "Ocean Runner" to Water Caye excursion since this is the same excursion used by Silversea, the luxury cruise line.

[evarb1]

I'm selected South Water Caye Island, based on my research.

 

http://www.belizeit.com/south-water-caye-marine-reserve.html

[MJC]

We chose Water Caye too, after hearing reports that Sergeants Caye was crowded. I'm hoping that the higher price for the former will mean fewer people choose it. We are experienced snorkelers and prefer it when there is less splashing which scares the fish away.

 

If nobody posts about Water Caye by the time we're back (end of March), I'll do a brief review.

[2Okies]

http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=1971372

 

See the comments on this thread I started. We just came back from cruising on Carnival Magic. We took the Sergeant Caye snorkel trip. This thread might help you decide.