I have been cruising for nearly 60 years starting as a 9-year-old in 1965. I have sailed on many cruise lines from Carnival to Norwegian America and have seen the evolution over the years. I have loved every cruise and cruise line. I am an extrovert (wife introvert) and love the roll calls and mingling and speaking with others. I must say the only dining issue we ever had was on Carnival in 1989. We were placed at a table for ten with a couple whose husband asked me every time he saw me if I had a gun both in the restaurant and elsewhere on the ship, simply because I was from NY. Regarding NCL specifically, I do think they get it right. I love the freestyle concept, casual dress and the ability to eat when we want and without the requirement of eating with others if we do not want to. While I am not crazy about Rope Courses or Go-Karts, my grandchildren who will be with us on The Joy in 2 weeks can't wait to use them. Therefore, there is something for everyone.
Mike A