If you thought Little French Key was a long way definitely don’t do the most popular run to West Bay. Maya Key is certainly a safe, convenient excursion on Roatan.
There are lots of other reasons why people have strong objections to Little French Key but I know there are also avid supporters. We have never been to Little French Key so can’t pass judgment one way or the other.
Nachi is certainly quieter than Paradise Beach (apples to oranges) and can be a relaxing change if you only have “older “ people in your group, who don’t need entertainment. We don’t go too often on a cruise ship day because we don’t need AI, when we are on a ship, but go occasionally when staying on the island.