Infinity or Eclipse for April 2014 T/A?

[SantaAna,CA]

Hi, I am new to Celebrity and I'm looking at two transatlantic cruises, one on the Infinity and one on the Eclipse. Both are around 13 days; one goes to Bermuda on the way, the other to New York and Halifax. The Infinity's prices are a bit better, but the ship looks rather old. I just wondered if anyone who regularly sails on Celebrity could give me their opinions.

 

I'm also thinking about several categories of cabins; the forward oceanviews are a good price, but on the Atlantic..hm! I also like the aft balconies and wondered about Aqua class. Any input?

 

Solo lady traveler. Thank you!

[Orator]

Hi, I am new to Celebrity and I'm looking at two transatlantic cruises, one on the Infinity and one on the Eclipse. Both are around 13 days; one goes to Bermuda on the way, the other to New York and Halifax. The Infinity's prices are a bit better, but the ship looks rather old. I just wondered if anyone who regularly sails on Celebrity could give me their opinions.

 

I'm also thinking about several categories of cabins; the forward oceanviews are a good price, but on the Atlantic..hm! I also like the aft balconies and wondered about Aqua class. Any input?

 

Solo lady traveler. Thank you!

 

Personally I prefer Reflection or Silhouette since there is more time in Europe and they take a Southern Route. If I were to risk the Northern route I'd take Connie, but that's just me. If it comes down to your two choices and I'm forced to select, I'd choose Eclipse.

[bellagirl]

We just completed a TA on Infinity in April of this year. While any cruise is a good cruise for me, I would have to say that next time, I think I would prefer a newer ship. It's not that Infinity was dirty but I think I would prefer something more polished.

 

On the subject of cabins, we had a balcony close to the front of the ship, and the movement really bothered me. My hubby was ok, but I was forced to wear the wristbands throughout the voyage. Again, not a big deal, but just something to make note of. By the way, the wristbands really do work!

 

Our itinerary was Ft. Lauderdale-Harwich, England with stops in the Azores, Brugges and France.

 

Shelly

[Happy Cruiser 6143]

I would definitely pick the Eclipse over the Infinity. The service on our Infinity TA last spring left a lot to be desired.