What is your favorite item on O'Sheehan's menu?

[LrgPizza]

David Sobe posted pics of the sundae menu here in his Getaway review from Feb. 2015.

 

http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showpost.php?p=45779558&postcount=15

[shealea]

The Ice cream bar in O'Sheehans has got to be the best kept secret on the ship.. There is no listing for it and is a separate menu from the O'sheehans menu, you need to ask for .. It cost a few bucks extra , But Oh so worth it..

 

Well, darn. Wish I would have known about it! Ice cream of any kind is my favorite dessert!!!!

[TrumpyNor]

The Ice cream bar in O'Sheehans has got to be the best kept secret on the ship.. There is no listing for it and is a separate menu from the O'sheehans menu, you need to ask for .. It cost a few bucks extra , But Oh so worth it..

 

And now I know as well - thank you for the tip!!! :D:D:D

Plus that I now have plenty of recommendations to try out, so again thank you to everyone who have responded!

Edited March 30, 2015 by TrumpyNor

[newmexicoNita]

Is this restaurant also on the Pearl?

 

yes it is; for us, it is just like any old fashion diner. It isn't "wow" food, but a good place to grab a late dinner or eat when getting back from a tour. We usually eat there (or should say ate at the old Blue Lagoon) about 3 or 4 times on a cruise. It hits the spot as long as no one expects it to be top of the line food. The biggest problem we have had is the service; sometimes it is really slow and certainly overly friendly it is not!!!! I can't wait to try it on the Pearl: love fish and chips.

[RikkuCat]

Does anyone know if there is a smaller version of the brownie sundae available? I know, I could order it and just not eat it all...but it seems like a terrible crime to waste iced cream.

[mpk218]

Does anyone know if there is a smaller version of the brownie sundae available? I know, I could order it and just not eat it all...but it seems like a terrible crime to waste iced cream.

 

Nope ... sorrry your going to have to eat it ALLLLLLLL :D

[david_sobe]

The prices are very reasonable. That giant hot fudge sundae only costs $4. Perfect for 2 unless you are hungry. The malts are $3.