Rccl Enchantment vs NCL Jade

[kaykels]

I am going to book a 4 night sailing and both of these ships are about the same price. I sailed Enchantment twice and loved it. Great value for a little ship. And Coco Cay is heaven !

     I don’t know much about NCL. Jade has an extra stop in Key West, which I love. There are many dining options and 3 specialty dinings are included in the price. 

     Just wondering for those that sailed both - how does Great Stirrup Cay compared to Coco ? And how does Jade compare to Enchantment?  

     

[smplybcause]

GSC is the island right next to Coco - so if ships miss Coco they usually miss GSC too. A bit bigger island - or at least currently bigger guest space the Coco. When are you going? I think the stage of construction Coco will be under when you go would be a deciding factor. I like both, GSC might be a little more rocky in the water, but it definitely wasn't as rocky as that beach at Labade. GSC does have a taco stand on it for another food option besides the bbq. I like both - and excluding construction I don't think I'd personally make the choice based on the islands, it would come down to ship, other stops, and perks. 

[kaykels]

Not basing it on the private island. More interested in ship comparison 

[smplybcause]

Ah. You asked both questions - but I only have a response to the private islands as I haven't been on Jade. 

[jenniferop]

I have sailed EoS twice and Jade once-  enjoyed both but liked Jade as a ship more - especially now after the dry dock upgrades.

[FL-Cruzer]

I am going on Enchantment  for the first time with Royal.  I am a big fan of NCL for the shows,the management team as well as the crew.  Their 3 and 4 day cruise included drinks.  There shows are some of the best I have seen at sea.  My suggestion would be go NCL, 3-4 day cruises are more about the ship and not the ports.  Enjoy

Edited November 11, 2018 by FL-Cruzer
miss spelling