Help with NYC hotel for 3

[ciship]

In March, our family (yes, we have the teenager too) drove from Toronto for a Norwegian Spirit cruise. Like you, we researched NY hotels and found them to be almost as expensive as our cruise for 3! We stayed in Jersey City at the Doubletree Suites (great hotel, great location...right on the Hudson River, large rooms with King bed and double sofa bed) for the night before the cruise. The PATH (train) station was a short walk away and we were in Manhattan 10 minutes later for $1.50 each. The hotel cost about $250 (Canadian) for the night. The next day we just drove through the Holland tunnel to the Manhattan pier.

 

This summer we're on the QM2 in August and when we priced the Jersey City Doubletree Suites again (for 2 nights this time) the price was going to be $750!! We searched again and found the Sheraton Suites-on-the Hudson (in Weehawken...3 miles from the Doubletree) for nearly half that price. It has a ferry station adjacent to the hotel property and we'll enjoy taking that to get into Manhattan this time. Since we're driving again, we'll just drive to the Brooklyn pier.

 

If you're driving, staying in New Jersey is an excellent option. If you're flying it could be a very expensive ride from there to your pier!

 

Great info!! Thank you for taking the time. I'm checking into it TODAY!!

[Budget Queen]

I like staying in Manhatten since all my activites are there. It's especially convenient to be able to go back and forth to the hotel during the day if needed. I stay at the Super 8. Easy to book/cancel online. Key is to book, then keep checking rates. My last 2 trips did have significant rate drops, including the week between Christmas and New Year's, which ended up being $150/night from orginal booking of $250.

 

The low rates are gone forever in NYC.

[ciship]

I like staying in Manhatten since all my activites are there. It's especially convenient to be able to go back and forth to the hotel during the day if needed. I stay at the Super 8. Easy to book/cancel online. Key is to book, then keep checking rates. My last 2 trips did have significant rate drops, including the week between Christmas and New Year's, which ended up being $150/night from orginal booking of $250.

 

The low rates are gone forever in NYC.

 

I had read so many good things about Super 8 that it was the first place I checked to stay. Unfortunately, they are showing that they cannot accomodate a family of five. If anyone knows differently, please let me know. We need a hotel that can take all five of us comfortably if anyone has suggestions.

[BlueHerons]

Don't stay in New Jersey. If you are sightseeing in Manhattan, stay in Manhattan. You should be able to find reasonable accommodations from this list. These aren't hotels I'm just throwing out there; I've either stayed in every one of these or had an immediate family member who did.

 

One last thing, if you stay in New Jersey, you'll spend lots of time and money dicking around getting back and forth to your hotel.

 

Try Apple Core Hotel Group (five hotels)

http://www.applecorehotels.com/

 

The Milford Plaza (I've stayed here recently and it is fine)

http://www.milfordplaza.com/

 

The Empire Group (The Travel Inn, The Newton, and Americana are reasonable)

http://www.newyorkhotel.com/

 

The Pod Hotel (formerly The Pickwick Arms)

http://www.pickwickarms.com/

 

The New York Salisbury

http://www.nycsalisbury.com/

[Budget Queen]

It is going to be tough finding lodging for 5 in NYC. Most have a max occup of 4. You are correct, the Super 8 only has 1 or 2 beds, max. 4.

[ciship]

Don't stay in New Jersey. If you are sightseeing in Manhattan, stay in Manhattan. You should be able to find reasonable accommodations from this list. These aren't hotels I'm just throwing out there; I've either stayed in every one of these or had an immediate family member who did.

 

One last thing, if you stay in New Jersey, you'll spend lots of time and money dicking around getting back and forth to your hotel.

 

Try Apple Core Hotel Group (five hotels)

http://www.applecorehotels.com/

 

The Milford Plaza (I've stayed here recently and it is fine)

http://www.milfordplaza.com/

 

The Empire Group (The Travel Inn, The Newton, and Americana are reasonable)

http://www.newyorkhotel.com/

 

The Pod Hotel (formerly The Pickwick Arms)

http://www.pickwickarms.com/

 

The New York Salisbury

http://www.nycsalisbury.com/

 

Really appreciate your efforts of all the links to hotels. The only one in the group that can accommodate five people is the Salisbury. I'm checking in to rates and reviews right now. Thanks for your help!!

[80/80 Girl]

Hey there - was searching the threads 'cuz we're going to go on Crown in November. Too bad we won't be able to sail together again!

 

George and I love living in Key West and hope you'll visit us. I work for the city of KW. Go to their website; I am the budget analyst. :) Our office is above the Wyland Gallery on Duval. I know....cry me a river.

 

Hope our paths will cross again.

 

Come see us!

 

Lynn

[emrmom]

My daughter and I stayed at the Salisbury last summer for a week and it was really ideal. It's a little older, but the rooms were clean and comfortable and the morning breakfast room was a nice way to start the day. The staff was really friendly and helpful. We just had a regular room, but they also have suites, even up to two bedrooms. There were a lot of families staying there. It's right across the street from Carnegie Hall and just a couple blocks from Central Park. The subway station is right at the corner. For such a great location, I thought their rates were very reasonable.

I'd stay there with my whole family pre-cruise, but they were filled on my dates. Good luck with yours!

 

Cindy

[tinlizzy]

Just got this hotel for July for 5 nights. Avg. $225/night. Includes breakfast.

http://www.wingateinns.com/Wingate/control/home

 

Hampton Inn also includes breakfast. Around the same price. Has two queen beds.

http://www.hamptoninn.com/en/hp/hotels/index.jhtml?ctyhocn=NYCHSHX

 

I booked Marritt Brooklyn Bridge for 7/14 for $169+tax with a senior discount on their website.

 

Good site. This San Carlos hotel offers breakfast also

http://travel.ian.com/index.jsp;jsid=bdecLqcbCR4Gsdgm7bDdr?departureMonth=6&pageName=hotAvail&hotnetrates=true&isHRN=true&mode=2&requestKey=088A4A100352013328&numberOfRooms=1&currencyCode=USD&arrivalDay=14&room-0-child-total=1&supplierType=E&cid=91635&room-0-child-0-age=16&additionalDataString=&departureDay=20&locale=en_US&submit=true&room-0-adult-total=3&arrivalMonth=6&hotelID=125871&rateRulesError=true

 

Finally Roger Smith hotel includes breakfast.

http://www.rogersmith.com/

[tinlizzy]

I couldn't find where I had written these down...both will accommodate 5 ppl.

 

http://secondhomesecondavenue.com/page/o1f0/Guest_Rooms_and_Rates.html

It's extra large but I believe I scouted reviews and it's a walk-up. $275/night + tax - also has min. stay requirements.

 

http://www.cosmohotel.com/info/index.html#twodouble_bed

Better choice for $240 with tax/night - No picture but they have a room with 2 queens and a sofa

[ciship]

Just got this hotel for July for 5 nights. Avg. $225/night. Includes breakfast.

http://www.wingateinns.com/Wingate/control/home

 

Hampton Inn also includes breakfast. Around the same price. Has two queen beds.

http://www.hamptoninn.com/en/hp/hotels/index.jhtml?ctyhocn=NYCHSHX

 

I booked Marritt Brooklyn Bridge for 7/14 for $169+tax with a senior discount on their website.

 

Good site. This San Carlos hotel offers breakfast also

http://travel.ian.com/index.jsp;jsid=bdecLqcbCR4Gsdgm7bDdr?departureMonth=6&pageName=hotAvail&hotnetrates=true&isHRN=true&mode=2&requestKey=088A4A100352013328&numberOfRooms=1&currencyCode=USD&arrivalDay=14&room-0-child-total=1&supplierType=E&cid=91635&room-0-child-0-age=16&additionalDataString=&departureDay=20&locale=en_US&submit=true&room-0-adult-total=3&arrivalMonth=6&hotelID=125871&rateRulesError=true

 

Finally Roger Smith hotel includes breakfast.

http://www.rogersmith.com/

 

I'm not having much luck yet tinlizzy, but I'm sure enjoying the pursuit of your leads!! The hotels are either sold out or don't have anything left to accommodate five people. Have you ever heard of Best Western Hospitality House or Radio City Apartments? REALLY appreciate your efforts. Keep em coming when you have time. I'm looking up everything you give me!!!

[tinlizzy]

ciship-

No problem I've been researching my own land vaca in NYC. What are the exact dates you're going and what's the break down of the 5 ppl (adults + kids & ages)? That would really help me help you look.

 

Have heard of those hotels (apts really) - name only.

[ciship]

ciship-

No problem I've been researching my own land vaca in NYC. What are the exact dates you're going and what's the break down of the 5 ppl (adults + kids & ages)? That would really help me help you look.

 

Have heard of those hotels (apts really) - name only.

 

We will be there POST cruise July 30-Aug 2. Three Adults and two children (14 and 10). Would prefer to be near Central Park area, but really will consider anything that will allow all of us to stay together without costing a fortune.

 

I tried the Salisbury. It was Sold Out.

[tinlizzy]

ciship

 

I found a good deal - maybe too good to be true. E-mail me at eg800@msn.com and I'll tell you about it.

 

Liz

[tinlizzy]

ciship-

 

I had found an rental by owner apartment for 300/week but the price was what I thought, a misprint. Should have been 300/night.

[tinlizzy]

ciship- Here's a thread from Fodor's about accommodations for 5 in NYC. Talks about Radio City Apts.

http://www.fodors.com/forums/threadselect.jsp?fid=1

 

I don't think the link works. Go to fodors and their talk boards. Highlight new york then type hotel in midtown for family of 5

[tinlizzy]

ciship-

 

After much searching I found an apt that sleeps up to 8. 4 bedrooms/3 baths in a high-rise one block up from the LeParker Meridian, one block from "the pond" in Central Park, two blocks from Carnegie Hall. $180-200/night! There are pictures of the apt on-line. Did I mention it has a terrace with views of the city.

Look- a view from the window

 

I'm not posting the site. 600 ppl have viewed this thread and it will be gone if I do.

 

Liz

[tinlizzy]

I'm on a roll now!:D ....inexpensive, beautiful apts for families.

 

http://www.villa4vacation.com/vacation-rental/Manhattan/440088.aspx

 

http://www.ppbo.com/vacation-rental/4502#summary

 

http://www.subletinthecity.com/property/2158

 

http://www.mediavacationrentals.com/US/property.php?view=19673 free parking/pool.....same address, different apt http://www.squamishhousing.com/property_main.cfm?propertyid=281 same apt on a monthly site http://www.roomdetective.com/detail.asp?room_id=998 he lists a Seattle phone number- job transfer maybe? Works for Microsoft maybe?

 

Anyone finding these helpful? :o

 

Liz

[ciship]

I'm on a roll now!:D ....inexpensive, beautiful apts for families.

 

http://www.villa4vacation.com/vacation-rental/Manhattan/440088.aspx

 

http://www.ppbo.com/vacation-rental/4502#summary

 

http://www.subletinthecity.com/property/2158

 

http://www.mediavacationrentals.com/US/property.php?view=19673 free parking/pool.....same address, different apt http://www.squamishhousing.com/property_main.cfm?propertyid=281 same apt on a monthly site http://www.roomdetective.com/detail.asp?room_id=998 he lists a Seattle phone number- job transfer maybe? Works for Microsoft maybe?

 

Anyone finding these helpful? :o

 

Liz

 

LOL!! I'm just trying to keep up with you LIZ!! Yes, I'm finding them VERY helpful. I enjoy looking and researching everything you put on this thread. That's my big Saturday night plans tonight.....checking out these options!! Thank you!!!!!!!!!1

[tinlizzy]

ciship- The least expensive apt. exactly in the location you wanted is the first one I posted (post #42). I can post the site but you'll have to look into it quickly. Do you want me to e-mail you the site or post it on-line?

[ciship]

ciship- The least expensive apt. exactly in the location you wanted is the first one I posted (post #42). I can post the site but you'll have to look into it quickly. Do you want me to e-mail you the site or post it on-line?

 

Please email me at ciship@aol.com

 

Thank you SO much tinlizzy!!!

[madelinerose]

http://www.vrbo.com/61305

 

http://www.vrbo.com/107576

 

http://www.vrbo.com/22895

http://www.vrbo.com/82410

 

http://www.vrbo.com/111752

http://www.vrbo.com/120206

 

http://www.vrbo.com/115340

http://www.vrbo.com/117050

[ciship]

http://www.vrbo.com/61305

 

http://www.vrbo.com/107576

 

http://www.vrbo.com/22895

http://www.vrbo.com/82410

 

http://www.vrbo.com/111752

http://www.vrbo.com/120206

 

http://www.vrbo.com/115340

http://www.vrbo.com/117050

 

Thank you for your efforts madelinerose! I looked at everyone of these!