Sailed the Allure in 2011. Our 7th cruise & it was my VERY FAVORITE CRUISE EVER.
(at the time...also, didn't sail Celebrity for the 1st time until 2012)
Sailed the Edge in 2021(14th cruise)--and I was BLOWN AWAY.
Celebrity does food & service better than RCCL overall.
That combined with the elevated experience in E-class has me obsessed with E-class.
Sailed Edge 2 weeks that time, Apex in March & have Beyond booked 2x this year.
I loved Allure because there were so many things to do! But bigger ships give you that in general.
I love Eclass because it is still big enough to have plenty to do, but the ships are the most beautiful I've sailed, the service continues to be very good & the food is SO good--MDRs best at sea imo (mainstream lines--have never sailed luxury lines) But their fine dining--OH WOW.
Honestly, there is NO NEED to do fine dining--MDR is THAT good.
But their fine dining is over the top.
Eden was 2 entirely different menus on each ship & both meals some of the best we have ever had.
We are doing Le Voyage on Beyond (reviews are amazing) & managed to snag Chef's Table.