I believe the as you wish encompasses all dining seleactions, not just open. That seems to have caused a lot of confusion with people. I'm not sure open was conceived so people could dine at all different times. I usually dine around 6pm. I don't fluctuate much from that. It's really not just for people who want to be all over the map. I don't have any desire to eat with the same people every night at 5 or whenever hal does their early dining now. Thats too early on holidays. Plus it's always been quite difficult to get the early dining. I eat mostly at specialty restaurants, and it wouldn't be cool to take a place in traditional when I'll never be there.