I'm against anything that would put more passengers into the Lounges/Clubs.
I'm sure there are Pinnacle passengers that get an exemption for their guests.
GSs on any Radiance class are not under the Windjammer, except for 1600. You may occasionally hear pool chairs, but it's not bothersome. 1600 is a disaster, you'll listen to chairs scraping the outside Windjammer deck all day.
The 12 yo should get the cup with the soda package.
I see your point but, the sequence of events indicates she was supposed to get the cup. They actually should have received two.
I'm not disagreeing with you! You can stand on the high moral ground all you want (and there is no reason why you shouldn't). Drink package stealing is a national sport.