I think that in addition to different perspectives on the decor, we are seeing different perspectives on what we expect from a bar. Some like a nice lounge with comfortable chairs and good servers and some prefer a compatico bar - by which I mean a commodious bar with ample chairs, friendly denizens, and expert interactive bartenders.
With a pretty cramped bar situated such that the bartenders can see only a portion of the lounge and such that any queue to the restrooms impinges on the bar’s airspace, I’d say the Retreat is a lounge with an afterthought bar (Edge didn’t have one at all). We’ve enjoyed comfortable lounges and compatico (yeah, I made up this label … and sober, too) bars. Our favorite bars offer us a choice.