how can you call it a steakhouse and not serve a porterhouse?

[H82seaUgo]

yet they changed the name from supper club?

 

and the raised the price.

 

come on carnival! bring back the porterhouse!

[Tapi]

Don't complain about selection. There's fried chicken and meatloaf at the MDR now! ;)

 

Seriously, I agree. I loved that 24 oz cut. That's what I USED to order!

[MississippiMom]

Don't complain about selection. There's fried chicken and meatloaf at the MDR now! ;)

 

Seriously, I agree. I loved that 24 oz cut. That's what I USED to order!

 

You might want to remember that other nationalities board Carnival. My South American grandfather insisted on fried chicken as his first meal every time he visited his children and grandchildren in the US. He lived in an area where beef and seafood were readily available, but chicken was considered a very special treat.

The steakhouse would seem ridiculous to him, because he could get steak at any time back home.

[Sargent_Schultz]

Order the New York and the Filet and maybe they will throw the bone in for free. Problem solved.

[iluvdoxies]

Order the New York and the Filet and maybe they will throw the bone in for free. Problem solved.

 

you cant order 2 steaks

 

More cost cutting from Carnival

[Jeffy294]

yet they changed the name from supper club?

 

and the raised the price.

 

come on carnival! bring back the porterhouse!

 

I kinda agree with you. I had the porterhouse a couple of times. To me it was just bragging rights eating the big bastard. I enjoy the other cuts much better and don't feel over stuffed. I am probably in the minority in this but I thought the filet was much better. But the cutbacks suck, that I agree with.

[IslandToIsland]

I always order the fillet. I have wanted to try the porterhouse, but that thing is freakin huge! After all gotta save room for the chocolate sampler. :D

[AZ Karaoke Girl]

Their filet mignon is awesome. After the first time, I won't bother with anything else. It is the best meat I ever tasted.

[H82seaUgo]

Order the New York and the Filet and maybe they will throw the bone in for free. Problem solved.

 

not for 70 bucks, i won't.

[CapeCodCruiser]

H82 - don't you see how BRILLIANT they are cutting the Porterhouse!:rolleyes:

 

Personally I'm a Ribeye gal - if they cut that then no more steakhouse for me!

[ryanpatricksmom]

I wonder how many people actually finished it when it was offered? I couldn't eat 24 oz of meat if you had a gun to my head. :o

 

I'm not supporting the decision, but I do wonder if there was a lot of waste associated with the porterhouse.

[bitemyfly]

I wonder how many people actually finished it when it was offered? I couldn't eat 24 oz of meat if you had a gun to my head. :o

 

I'm not supporting the decision, but I do wonder if there was a lot of waste associated with the porterhouse.

 

I was a fan of the porterhouse , and I think there was probaly 16 to 18 oz of meat once u discard the bone

But I still enjoy the rib eye ! And eat there at least twice a week

[gobucks_43228]

No kidding!! Very disappointing. We will miss it for certain. Husband finished it twice, my son (age 13 at the time) finished his before anyone. I ordered it for bragging rights, I finished it but wasted my sides and dessert :(

[cruiserNC]

I agree hard to call it a steakhouse without a Porterhouse. I do think the cut was much bigger than it should have been but that is my favorite cut of steak. Not for bragging rights as i never attempted to eat it all.

[Sargent_Schultz]

you cant order 2 steaks

 

More cost cutting from Carnival

 

You can order as many steaks as you want; just have to pay for them. How is that cost cutting? :p

[YubaSutter]

I kinda agree with you. I had the porterhouse a couple of times. To me it was just bragging rights eating the big bastard. I enjoy the other cuts much better and don't feel over stuffed. I am probably in the minority in this but I thought the filet was much better. But the cutbacks suck, that I agree with.

 

The porterhouse was good. Not as good as the 32 ounce prime rib we have at the local restaurant.

[jrmende63]

I, too, miss the porterhouse. Yes, I did order it and YES I ate every bite! But I am a steak kinda gal!

[iluvdoxies]

You can order as many steaks as you want; just have to pay for them. How is that cost cutting? :p

 

Keep those rose colored glasses on Sarge

[drosphot]

There's talk of a demonstration at the steakhouse! Let's make signs and go protest! :rolleyes:

[halos]

Personally I'm a Ribeye gal - if they cut that then no more steakhouse for me!

Me too. Ribeye is awesome.

[tampacrew]

Those steaks where always a little bit TOO rich to me anyhow, there's other food on the menu, no need to starve!

[iluvdoxies]

You can order as many steaks as you want; just have to pay for them. How is that cost cutting? :p

 

Keep those rose colored glasses on Sarge

[H82seaUgo]

Me too. Ribeye is awesome.

 

i hate fatty meat!

[Indianaseadog]

cant miss what I've never had. And I love a good ribeye and the one I had at the "steakhouse" or whatever you want to call it was more than worth my money. And they can call it a steak house or dog house...dont care. If I think I'm getting my money's worth, I'll go back.

[vols_159]

i hate fatty meat!

 

fat is where all the flavor is at