Taking a vote

[MotherofTrips]

We have 4 nights of specialty dining. One will be used for Cirque the other for Teppanyaki. Which only leaves 2 left. We all like filet mignon, 4 out of 6 like seafood. What other 2 should we do?

1. Cagneys 2. Le Bistro 3. Moderno

Edited February 23, 2016 by MotherofTrips

[sadiecat]

Cagneys and LeBistro. We have never cared for Moderno and have tried it three times.

[tel2]

Hi!

 

Just to make sure you are aware, the SDP typically has not included Cirque. There was a PP surcharge for Cirque even with the package. I believe it was 10.00 pp for regular seats; 15. pp for premium seats, and 35. pp for VIP seating.

 

And in answer to your question, my choice would depend on what I was looking for, i.e., a quiet romantic dinner for 2, Le Bistro hands down; in the mood for a steakhouse type dinner, Cagneys. Moderno would probably always be my last choice. It isn't done as well as it is done on land, and I get annoyed that they bring all the cheaper cuts first, i.e., chicken and sausage and ribs. My own view is that they hope you will fill up on the salad bar and not have room for much filet etc when it is finally served. But having said that, we have often said - don't bring us any chicken or pork, we only want the beef cuts, and they have usually paid attention and accommodated....

 

Terry

[TheDougOut]

Cagneys and LeBistro.

 

This has my vote.

[mugtech]

this has my vote.

ditto:d

[MotherofTrips]

Hi!

 

 

 

Just to make sure you are aware, the SDP typically has not included Cirque. There was a PP surcharge for Cirque even with the package. I believe it was 10.00 pp for regular seats; 15. pp for premium seats, and 35. pp for VIP seating.

 

 

 

And in answer to your question, my choice would depend on what I was looking for, i.e., a quiet romantic dinner for 2, Le Bistro hands down; in the mood for a steakhouse type dinner, Cagneys. Moderno would probably always be my last choice. It isn't done as well as it is done on land, and I get annoyed that they bring all the cheaper cuts first, i.e., chicken and sausage and ribs. My own view is that they hope you will fill up on the salad bar and not have room for much filet etc when it is finally served. But having said that, we have often said - don't bring us any chicken or pork, we only want the beef cuts, and they have usually paid attention and accommodated....

 

 

 

Terry

 

 

Thank you. Yes I am aware of the surcharge. I originally thought that just having the package allowed you to get in for that surgage but then I found out that it counts as one of your days :(

 

I'll be with my husband, mother and 3 kids. We were never at a Brazilian steakhouse so that's why it was one of my options.

[Mrs. H.]

OMG I love LeBistro!!! :D

[MotherofTrips]

My son loves seafood. Will he be able to get it at these places. I would go to the seafood restaurant but my girls don't eat it

[Huntingdon1701]

I'd go with Cagneys and Le Bistro, but given you say you've never been to anything like Moderno, why not try that instead of Le Bistro? I do enjoy Moderno and it is a different experience to the others.

 

I personally would rate Le Bistro slightly higher than Cagneys, but given you say most of your group like Filet mignon you might find more to please everyone at Cagneys.

[casofilia]

With children/young people the le Bistro #1 and Cagneys #2. Moderno would be #205.

 

Mike

[LrgPizza]

Cagney's and Le Bistro

[TheDougOut]

There are seafood options at both, depending on what he likes. Here's a sampling...

 

Split whole lobster at Cagney's

 

Seafood medley appetizer at LeBistro

 

Freebie fried seafood basket at O'Sheehans (at least on the Escape)

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Forums mobile app

[MotherofTrips]

There are seafood options at both, depending on what he likes. Here's a sampling...

 

Split whole lobster at Cagney's

 

Seafood medley appetizer at LeBistro

 

Freebie fried seafood basket at O'Sheehans (at least on the Escape)

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Forums mobile app

 

 

My son loves lobster! How much extra do you have to pay for that with SDP?

[TheDougOut]

My son loves lobster! How much extra do you have to pay for that with SDP?

 

$0 - You're permitted to select 1 entrée, and the split lobster is an option.

[MotherofTrips]

$0 - You're permitted to select 1 entrée, and the split lobster is an option.

 

 

It comes all split and clean??? Oh he will love this! I thought I read somewhere that you can pay a fee in MDR to get lobster. Is this true?

[TheDougOut]

It comes all split and clean??? Oh he will love this! I thought I read somewhere that you can pay a fee in MDR to get lobster. Is this true?

 

Yep, this is how it comes - split and cleaned. It's relatively small, probably the equivalent of a nice tail at a land-based restaurant.

 

You're right, there's also an a la carte option in the main dining room to order the split lobster. I ordered it both in the MDR and at Cagney's for a comparison, and they were identical.

[titangas]

Le Bistro twice.

 

Had 2 disappointing meals in Cagney's and 4 exceptional ones in Le Bistro

[geegee1]

Le Bistro and Cagney's. Did Moderno twice on the Breakaway. It wasn't worth it either time. Did it the second time just to see if it got better, in our opinion it did not. It actually got worse.

[Irene7]

Cagneys and LeBistro. We have never cared for Moderno and have tried it three times.

 

I second this vote.

[Le Cruisester]

I have not been to Cagney's yet but I would eat at Le Bistro every night and be a very very happy man!!!

[MotherofTrips]

Yep, this is how it comes - split and cleaned. It's relatively small, probably the equivalent of a nice tail at a land-based restaurant.

 

 

 

You're right, there's also an a la carte option in the main dining room to order the split lobster. I ordered it both in the MDR and at Cagney's for a comparison, and they were identical.

 

 

Sorry so many questions. Do you know if it's available in both MDR and is it available any day? Since we have to eat there 3 nights maybe he should try something different at Cagneys and get the lobster there.

[TheDougOut]

Sorry so many questions. Do you know if it's available in both MDR and is it available any day? Since we have to eat there 3 nights maybe he should try something different at Cagneys and get the lobster there.

 

On any given night, the menus will be the same across all 3 main dining rooms, and the a la carte options are always present.

 

Cagney's also has a nice surf/turf combo, which worked out better portion-wise for me (more filling).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Forums mobile app

Edited February 23, 2016 by TheDougOut

[MotherofTrips]

On any given night, the menus will be the same across all 3 main dining rooms, and the a la carte options are always present.

 

Cagney's also has a nice surf/turf combo, which worked out better portion-wise for me (more filling).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Forums mobile app

 

 

This has my vote!

[maryisme]

Just off Breakaway on Sunday - Moderno was nothing special. Cagney's and Bistro have my vote.

[ryarger]

If you're on BA or GA, consider paying the additional upcharge for Ocean Blue if you're looking for seafood. You can't go wrong with Cagney's, Le Bistro *or* Moderno IMO. They're all fantastic. I think Cagneys has a sea bass entree. That is pretty much heaven on a plate. But Le Bistro has the seafood bouillabaisse. Mmmmm...

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk