BAD MOVE: Moving cabin questions elsewhere

[MrPete]

The wealth of knowledge will be lost, mixing all cabin questions to a place I certainly won't be visiting.

 

Bad move, guys.

[hockeyluver]

The wealth of knowledge will be lost, mixing all cabin questions to a place I certainly won't be visiting.

 

Bad move, guys.

 

I have to agree, the majority of people come to this forum and dont venture into the others. I think they are getting carried away with catagorizing all the posts.

[Mysticks1]

The wealth of knowledge will be lost, mixing all cabin questions to a place I certainly won't be visiting.

 

Bad move, guys.

 

I agree - most of those questions will go unanswered if not on the main boards. Why not leave them on the main boards for 24 hours before moving them. That way they get answered before being moved and then they might eventually do some good for those looking for cabin information on that board.

[WHITESANDBLUESKIES]

Forgive me if this is a stupid question, but where were the cabin questions moved to?

[Mysticks1]

Forgive me if this is a stupid question, but where were the cabin questions moved to?

 

http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=430149

 

Cabin selection tips. When a thread is moved it will state "moved" and you can click on it and it will take you to the forum that it was moved to.

[elon mom]

I agree with mystick1- at least leave them long enough to get a few replies..... I find myself sticking to the main board and not looking at the others....takes too much time especially when I am doing this at work;)

[texas greeneyes]

The wealth of knowledge will be lost, mixing all cabin questions to a place I certainly won't be visiting.

 

Bad move, guys.

 

I agree with you, Mr. Pete. (As usual.)

[mrdood]

it even kills the "search this forum" room number punching that I love...

 

 

...and I am one of the biggest advocates for keeping Carnival just Carnival and separating out non-Carnival information to Port Forums, Floataway etc. - and even I think this is a "running aground" kind of idea...

[beaming90]

I completely agree with all of you. :rolleyes:

[5668200]

Rarely do I go to the other sites.

[DqALEX]

The wealth of knowledge will be lost, mixing all cabin questions to a place I certainly won't be visiting.

 

Bad move, guys.

I never go anywhere but here and roll call

[zydecocruiser]

I predict this thread will be moved to blue jean heaven.

[habby]

it even kills the "search this forum" room number punching that I love...

 

 

...

 

Yeah, I need my chuckle a day from mrdood!

[rvrgirl]

I predict this thread will be moved to blue jean heaven.

 

Ya think;)

[BND]

So, why have a Carnival forum at all if questions pertaining only to Carnival are going to be moved? People come to the Carnival forum looking for info about Carnival Cruises and ships. The search feature already doesn't work most of the time, so this is just going to make this forum less user friendly. Rethink this please!

[ladycaveat]

The wealth of knowledge will be lost, mixing all cabin questions to a place I certainly won't be visiting.

 

Bad move, guys.

 

So true! Is it just me or does it seem like so many really good threads are being moved these days? I usually only read this board, the fashion board and the ports boards. I just have time to read bunches of different boards.

[Family Man]

I predict this thread will be moved to blue jean heaven.

Or actually poofed since he had the audacity to question..... :rolleyes:

[joepeka]

So, why have a Carnival forum at all if questions pertaining only to Carnival are going to be moved? People come to the Carnival forum looking for info about Carnival Cruises and ships. The search feature already doesn't work most of the time, so this is just going to make this forum less user friendly. Rethink this please!

Agree totally - people want to ask (and have answered) questions about Carnival cabins on the Carnival board. I only frequent the Carnival, HAL and Ports of Call boards.

[patrice1]

I agree with all of the above.

[hstrybuf]

I don't have time to read more than my roll call, Carnival and maybe a couple of other cruiseline specific forums. Some days, I don't even have time to read those! Pete, FWIW, I agree with you. They are going to get fewer answers on another forum when they are looking for something that is cruiseline specific.

[rada628]

I didn't realize this until you pointed it out and I think it stinks.

[enester]

The new category is a great place to go to ask a question.... but awful for getting an answer. I know I won't be surfing there to see if anyone is asking about a cabin I know something about......

[finoky]

It has been my observation that a lot more posts get moved from this section of CC than any other.

[cathyoo]

I would think the generic cabin thread would be fine for asking general cabin selection questions. However, if I have a question about a CARNIVAL cabin here is where I would look for help. Makes sense to me.

[baseballdad]

If you work for a living, how are you supposed to have time to look at that many boards?? And Who with ANSWERS would be looking over there?

 

Makes no sense at all!