New York City Hotels: Courtyard Times Square South or Millennium Hotel Broadway

[Jimbo]

New York City

 

Courtyard is on 40th Street and Millennium is on 44th Street.

 

Which hotel is nicer? Price is only about $20 more for the Millennium

 

One Night?

 

Anyone have an opinion, anyone stayed in both to compare for me?

 

Jimbo:)

[Chelley00]

We're staying at the Broadway Millienium in 3 weeks. I can give you a review then :) We booked it through TravelZoo and got a great deal!

[Jimbo]

Thanks, don't think you are going to be much help though, we are going on Saturday the 13th of June.

 

Just can't decide which hotel to book.

 

Jimbo:)

[binkysmom]

check tripadvisor dot com for reviews

[BlueHerons]

Honestly, location wise it is six of one; half dozen of another.

 

As far as the hotels go, the Millenium will be nicer but the rooms at the CbM may be a little larger.

 

I'd probably go for the Millenium.

[Jimbo]

I hadn't reserved the Millennium until I checked Travel Zoo which Chelley00 mentioned (Thank You)

 

I had found a price of $223 on Millennium website which wasn't cancellable,but on Travel Zoo they had a price of $230 which can be canceled so I reserved that.

 

So Courtyard is $203 and Millennium is now $230.

 

Now we have some more time to decide I guess.

 

Anyone else have any opinions of the 2 hotels?

 

Jimbo:)

[Jimbo]

check tripadvisor dot com for reviews

 

That is what is making this a tough decision, Courtyard is somehow ranked like

#28 and Millennium is ranked #129 out of 412 hotels in NYC.

 

Jimbo:)

[NYCRUISR]

Honestly, location wise it is six of one; half dozen of another.

 

As far as the hotels go, the Millenium will be nicer but the rooms at the CbM may be a little larger.

 

I'd probably go for the Millenium.

 

 

Me also. Location is right by Times Square. I commute to NYC every day from Long Island. Any city questions I can help you with, just ask.

 

John

[megr1125]

i take trip advisor reviews with a grain of salt.

 

i stay in marriotts all the time so i would pick that...but IIRC the millenium is closer to times square............

[NYCRUISR]

That is what is making this a tough decision, Courtyard is somehow ranked like

#28 and Millennium is ranked #129 out of 412 hotels in NYC.

 

Jimbo:)

 

 

Age maybe?

 

Incidently, if I never thanked you, you were instrumental in getting us to decide on a corner aft cabin. Thats all we do these days. So THANKS!!!!

[Jimbo]

Age maybe?

 

Incidently, if I never thanked you, you were instrumental in getting us to decide on a corner aft cabin. Thats all we do these days. So THANKS!!!!

 

 

Glad I could help, They are really nice aren't they?:D

 

Jimbo:)

[Jimbo]

i take trip advisor reviews with a grain of salt.

 

i stay in marriotts all the time so i would pick that...but IIRC the millenium is closer to times square............

 

 

Your a marriott snob:rolleyes: though....lol

 

I need other opinions.

 

Jimbo:)

[BlueHerons]

i take trip advisor reviews with a grain of salt.

 

i stay in marriotts all the time so i would pick that...but IIRC the millenium is closer to times square............

 

 

I ignore TA reviews completely. Half of them are either disgruntled employees or ones that have drank the KoolAid.

 

Are you a member of either Hilton's or Marriott's frequent stay program?

[GeniRich]

Anyone have an opinion,

Jimbo:)

 

I do but not about the hotels!

 

How's things been going? Hope all is well with you.

 

Rich

[Jimbo]

I do but not about the hotels!

 

How's things been going? Hope all is well with you.

 

Rich

 

Hi Rich, Things are fine here, how about with you? I see you just got off of Mariner, did you head north? I bet that was different.

 

Find anymore deals like we had on Freedom?

 

Jimbo:)

[Puffinater]

Hi Rich, Things are fine here, how about with you? I see you just got off of Mariner, did you head north? I bet that was different.

 

Find anymore deals like we had on Freedom?

 

Jimbo:)

 

Things are going well here. Yup we went north. It was a little cold but it was a fun trip. Got a great last minute deal but not sure it would equate to what we got on the Freedom.

We had just been to the Mexican Riviera in March on the Mariner and really enjoyed the ship so when this opportunity became available we jumped on it.

[GeniRich]

Jimbo just sent you an email with some additional Mariner info. Did not want to post it all here.

 

Rich

[megr1125]

Your a marriott snob:rolleyes: though....lol

 

I need other opinions.

 

Jimbo:)

 

dang.........at least i like the phillies................

 

it's also 20-30 bucks cheaper which buys what, 2 drinks???? lol!

 

how about the doubletree??? that's right there in the action!

 

(and i worked for marriott a LOOONG time ago....i HAVE tried to move some nights to Starwood or hyatt, but when stinkin marriott has cheaper rates! plus i am only 1.5 million points and 100 niights short of being platinum for life...not that THAT means anything anymore!:eek::rolleyes:)