My opinion is "extremely pro". We sailed Jan 2024. I had the bar set really low....based on the great deal and great cabin I had. What could I expect for "almost nothing"? As it turned out....it was a perfect cruise. Entertainment was good, brunch was very good.... Service was better than expected in the buffet (DH uses a cane so I generally am his butler....while I was running around for him, the staff was bringing him food).
The food in general was ok...nothing to write home about, but nobody starved.
Edited to add about the theatre: As someone else said, get there early. There was barely an inclination so if you're short, and not in the first row, you won't see much.