"But I think there’s still something very special about the Celebrity experience for me that I’ve still felt on this cruise."
That was a lovely story Charla and beautiful pics too. Wonderful! In 2021 we sailed retreat edge 3 times when they reopened after shutdown. We found then the above and beyond attitude you are talking about. In 2022 in retreat, it was gone in our experience. Which is why we skipped Celebrity in 2023. I hope you are right that it has come back. We are elite members and are giving them another chance in July.