I agree. I don’t want the constant attention of the staff and I like to do things myself. What has made me skew more towards suites and considering luxury lines (or the ship within a ship concept) is mostly to have more space in the pool area, better dining options, and priority for getting off and on the boat. I think Celebrity is a good option for a more elevated experience. We booked our 2nd Celebrity cruise for next spring. This time in a suite. I am looking forward to the dedicated, elevated dining experience (Luminae) and private lounge/sun deck. I’m sure I will venture to the other areas (often) but it’s nice to know I have a calm area if I need it. It’s port intensive (out of San Juan) so I will welcome the one sea day to just relax by the pool.
I was in a mini suite on NCL Breakaway in May and I thought the outdoor areas often seemed very crowded and awkward but the evening time in the bars and restaurants were nice (though they have some strict shoe requirements for men that were odd considering their boasting of being a more casual cruise experience). They had great talent for the production/stage shows, beating both Carnival and Celebrity, but I thought Carnival’s venue-rotating performers were better. Lunch offering was not great. I love Indian food and was disappointed in the buffet selection that I’ve heard great things about. The Haven pool area does not impress me and I don’t think it is a good value to me for its cost. I think the Prima class could change my opinion though (just not sure I’m ready for that price point).
I still like the Carnival experience (especially lunch options!) but finding a ship that has more pool areas with fewer people (regardless of age) has me looking for those ships with better serenity and Havana areas. I have not done the Havana area before and think I would only consider it on the Vista Class ships. I was supposed to go on Legend during COVID and am anxious to try the Spirit class Serenity area. I was on Mardi Gras and loved all the pool options but even with 50% capacity, it could be hard to find a lounger in the sun (but easy in a shaded area which I do want sometimes). I wouldn’t consider paying for their Havana area but maybe the Excel Suite. Although, on Elation, I actually enjoyed sitting up by the waterworks area since cooling off with a giant bucket of water is fun and it was less crowded in the lounging area. I don’t mind kids when they are in their element just having fun. It’s just annoying when they are jumping over you into the pool or hogging the hot tubs.