Cagneys...New York Strip or Ribeye

[timkatmom]

I have reservations at Cagneys. It is a subjective question..love both! But in your opinion, what is a better choice?

[kcwingwalker]

I'll go for the rib eye every time

[Cubechick]

LOL...and I go for the strip...

[Beaver1975]

I'm with Aimee, love the texture of a strip.

[chris153]

I would go twice!!

[Beaver1975]

I would go twice!!

 

...and then someone comes along and interjects logic. <grin>

[SissasMomE]

I have reservations at Cagneys. It is a subjective question..love both! But in your opinion, what is a better choice?

 

I love their strip!

[lhugheshome]

Ribeye...no contest! Way better flavour.

[SissasMomE]

Just FYI - my daughter got the ribs there, and she loved them. Just in case anyone was wondering ... :)

[garycarla]

Sort of goes with an earlier post... opinions. We all have them.

 

Probably the reason they have so many different items on the menu. Different people like different things.

[don't-use-real-name]

For a $10 surcharge you can have both !!!

For another $10 you can add Lobster (if they have it) !!!

 

If you buy the UDP come back later and have an instant replay !!!

 

There is a method to this madness - the menu is beginning to overwhelm

the taste buds.

 

So Bon Appetite on your Bon Voyage !

 

And remember the penalty laps you are going to have to do on the jogging

track or exercise machine ! LOL !

[jack300s]

Had all the steaks.....

 

1. Filet

2. Bone-in Ribeye

3. Porterhouse

4. New York Strip

Edited July 29, 2014 by jack300s

[jack300s]

Double post sorry

Edited July 29, 2014 by jack300s

[jonbgd]

NY doesn't have enough flavor always the ribeye

[Beaver1975]

Had all the steaks.....

 

1. Filet

2. Bone-in Ribeye

3. Porterhouse

4. New York Strip

 

....and, any answer to the question by the OP?

[Beaver1975]

For a $10 surcharge you can have both !!!

For another $10 you can add Lobster (if they have it) !!!

 

If you buy the UDP come back later and have an instant replay !!!

 

There is a method to this madness - the menu is beginning to overwhelm

the taste buds.

 

So Bon Appetite on your Bon Voyage !

 

And remember the penalty laps you are going to have to do on the jogging

track or exercise machine ! LOL !

 

....and?

 

Is there an answer for the OP's question?

Edited July 29, 2014 by Beaver1975

[CaliforniaDreamer]

....and, any answer to the question by the OP?

 

Yes.

 

I believe the poster was ranking the different meats.

[Novastar]

Ribeye gets my vote!

[biker@sea]

Ribeye

[GORDONCHICK]

Always the ribeye for me, but DH always goes for the filet.

[jack300s]

....and, any answer to the question by the OP?

 

The answer is #2 over #4 (ribeye over new york). I guess you missed it!

[Sizzlechest]

Le Bistro!

[TravelJoe]

I have reservations at Cagneys. It is a subjective question..love both! But in your opinion, what is a better choice?

 

I had the bison sirloin this trip -- it was excellent and something you can't get everywhere. I'm also a sirloin fan though; less fat than a ribeye and more texture, but as stated, very subjective and personal choice.

[newmexicoNita]

I'll go for the rib eye every time

 

I did the strip last time; it was great...The one time I did rib eye it had a lot of fat; some is fine, but there is a limit.

[Beaver1975]

Duplicate

Edited July 29, 2014 by Beaver1975