I've only been on one cruise (Koningsdam Alaska 2022), but have an upcoming Thanksgiving cruise (Nieuw Statendam). I thought your review was spot-on. I would have given my cruise a 9 out of 10, but admittedly it was because it was Alaska, the weather was fantastic, and my family are all ambiverts. I just hope my upcoming cruise matches the mystique, but we know it won't since the Caribbean isn't even worth the ink to write on our bucket list.