They'll probably ultimately charge for all desserts at CaB and perhaps move them all over to Gelato station on the M/S class. While that's disappointing, so are the desserts at CaB (so bland, not worth the calories) 😅 The cookies appear to be a better version of the cookies that are free, perhaps X will produce descent quality desserts if they charge. However, that has its own set of problems because like all cruise lines, the price will continually increase and the product, in this case the dessert recipes, will be continually be cheapened