Best Steak, Cagney's or Le Bistro?

[Platiumplus]

Off the menue now

[mdsgu]

On our last NCL cruise (Breakway, Nov 2018), my steak in LeBistro was much better than the one I had the next night in Cagney's.

[kochleffel]

I've never eaten beef steak of any sort in Le Bistro. While I have been very satisfied with the steaks in Cagney's, the best dining experience of all on NCL was lamb chops in Cagney's.

[FLAHAM]

The onion soup at Le Bistro is really third rate.  That said, I have had some very good entrees at Le Bistro.  

[Gigi57]

45 minutes ago, kochleffel said:

I've never eaten beef steak of any sort in Le Bistro. While I have been very satisfied with the steaks in Cagney's, the best dining experience of all on NCL was lamb chops in Cagney's.

My lamb at Cagneys on the Bliss left much to be desired.  Guess it just goes to show that the chef/cook can make or break a meal.😋 

[TrumpyNor]

I have over the years found it "strange" that the steaks that I have been served in Le Bistro always have been much more tender than the steaks in the steakhouse on board (Cagney's) - so on our last cruise I actually asked about it and was told that it is a very simple explanation for that: In Cagney's the steaks are cooked on a grill where the meat juice kind of "drips down below" and in Le Bistro the steaks are cooked on a hot plate keeping the meat juice inside the steak. 

[quercus alba]

All told, the filets are better whichever restaurant you pick for the trimmings.

[salzdt]

I had awesome lamb chops at LeBistro.  Hubby had steak.  He said it was good.

[pixiedust777]

On 3/19/2019 at 6:50 PM, sid_9169 said:

I was on the Breakaway about a month ago, and had the filet at Cagney's, Le Bistro, La Cucina, and Moderno... They were all good, but I personally rated the one at La Cucina first, Le Bistro second, Cagney's third, and Moderno last... Just my experience, YMMV...

Was on the same cruise in February and I totally agree with Sid_9169.

[DAllenTCY]

I've found Moderno's meats to be overly salted.

 

Cagney's and Le Bistro were cooked to order.....so not seasoned so much.

David

[Nclgetawaymenhoney]

Le bistro by far

[havenfan]

Another vote for Le Bistro over Cagney's the last few years.

[marti2282]

On 3/19/2019 at 7:03 PM, gmbhardy said:

 

I agree. The filet at La Cucina was the best.

Third vote for La Cucina !

[Love my butler]

On 3/19/2019 at 1:01 PM, Gigi57 said:

Going on Breakaway next month.  Opinions on where to get the best steak?

 

 

Eaten at LeBistro dozens of times and Cagney's hundreds of times.  Cagney's wins.