Jump to content

Voyager of the Seas 11/4/23 The Good, the Bad, & the Ugly


luckybecky
 Share

Recommended Posts

Hello Cruisers!

 

I have a lengthy commentary about our recent Western Caribbean cruise on the Voyager of the Seas. If you are interested, I welcome you to follow along. We had a good time, but this wasn’t my favorite cruise of all time. I have quite a few criticisms and I know some people don’t like to hear anything negative about their favorite cruise line. This was just our experience. YMMV. We still had a great time! Any opportunity to travel and every day on a cruise is a gift to us. We don’t let these little things ruin our time.

 

My adult daughter had some vacation time that she had to use soon, or lose it. And she had a birthday coming up, so we booked a last minute mother-daughter cruise out of Galveston.

 

We left San Antonio at 8:15am, arrived at the cruise port about 12. We parked at Park 2 Cruise, a few minutes’ walk to RC terminal. Make sure you have reservation because they were maxed out. We arrived at the terminal at 12:15. Our boarding time was 12:30-1:00.

 

The Good:

Easiest embarkation process ever! No one checked our boarding time, or else we were close enough that nobody cared. NO wait at all to check in, or for security. No lines whatsoever. The terminal was very nice. Lots of seating that looked comfortable, but we didn’t have to use it. Got right on board.

 

Also, they seemed completely unconcerned about booze smuggling. I had 2 bottles of wine in my suitcase (as allowed) which were not checked. Some cruise lines inspect every bottle to be sure you aren’t trying to smuggle on liquor. Likewise, coming back from Costa Maya, I had a nearly full bottle of water which sailed through security without being checked.

 

We went directly to our muster station, took maybe 30 seconds to check in. We had watched the short safety info in the app on the drive down.

 

Took the elevator to deck 11 to Windjammer, very crowded as expected but we miraculously found a table by the window. We ate light because we have Chops tonight. The buffet looked very typical. I just had a salad and some veggies so can’t really comment on the quality of the food because a salad is pretty basic. There seemed to be a good variety and everything looked good.

 

Here's the terminal

20231104_122503.thumb.jpg.0ec4c4ce96df773dad61448807520203.jpg

 

All aboard!

 

20231104_123433.thumb.jpg.cd4819a59247eb83d4a47bf1813f3e92.jpg

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Good

Cabins were ready at 1:00 on the dot, so as soon as we finished eating we were able to go to our cabin. I had carried my luggage on so I wanted to drop it off. LOVED the cabin. I am a balcony person. I always want a balcony. But this was a last minute trip that we really hadn’t planned or budgeted for, so I couldn’t justify the cost of a balcony. We went with Category 2T promenade view inside cabin 7591.

 

I was not looking forward to an inside cabin because our last inside cabin experience was poor. On Carnival Dream we had an inside that literally barely fit the bed. There was a tiny desk with a tiny stool. The bed took up the entire space. It was claustrophobic and I really didn’t like it. So I was very happy to see that this promenade view cabin had a small sofa and a bay window seat, as well as a chair (not just a tiny stool) at the desk. The window made it feel much more airy.

 

My daughter had left her suitcase with a porter outside. It was delivered to our room around 3:30 or so.

 

The Bad:

This cabin does not appear to be updated. I had read somewhere that this ship was updated just last year, but the cabin does not appear so. The outlets for example: two US and one European outlet at the desk. Newer or updated ships seem to be installing USB outlets, and ports near the bed. None of that here. The furnishings didn’t look new, and drawers didn’t open and close smoothly. Bathroom mirror looked very old, peeling around the edges. Telephone looked positively ancient, and didn’t look like it had been cleaned in years. It was pretty disgusting. Don’t get me wrong, the cabin was fine, but I’m just saying that it doesn’t appear to have been updated in a long time.

 

Beds needed separating. Our steward took care of that while we were at supper.

 

I unpacked, then we went and explored the ship. Made reservation for Izumi for later in the week (we tried to do it in the app but it wanted to charge us. We had pre purchased Chops +1 package so there should be no charge).

 

Here's the cabin

20231104_133543.thumb.jpg.cae7efcbef543d79ce9fc43bfb29284d.jpg

 

 

20231104_133555.thumb.jpg.5f9aec202ca57216b2f7c57deae04b96.jpg

 

20231104_133555.thumb.jpg.5f9aec202ca57216b2f7c57deae04b96.jpg

 

20231104_133602.thumb.jpg.a0288d2f51864d4f65db15fc863e1ef4.jpg

 

20231104_133610.thumb.jpg.4cd8e11e18ba5516a61f64fd1980d2a6.jpg

 

20231104_133637.thumb.jpg.08409ccaa861ec039af9ac8b24a8bc90.jpg

 

20231104_133649.thumb.jpg.3c78c1577456d9070d996f919f562361.jpg

 

20231104_133714.thumb.jpg.236bd5384e7fbfb87f9e5a29a7b67731.jpg

 

20231104_134103.thumb.jpg.24adfc39ea4d49f258b24855d65a11ae.jpg

 

 

Here is an example of what I mean about not being updated, the mirror is worn. But the room was fine.

 

20231109_000710.thumb.jpg.fdbcb2b7d63bf803b6364c6b61731fe3.jpg

 

  • Like 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Bad:

We reserved my time dining. Not impressed. Doesn’t start until 6:45! Every other ship I’ve ever been on, I’m pretty sure they all started at 5:30.

 

We like to eat early so we have lots of time in the evening for shows/activities. And you can’t just sign in on the app when you are ready to eat, as some cruises have us do. You have to reserve. I don’t know what happens if your plans change and you miss or want to change your reservation time. This does not seem like “My Time” dining. It seems like the times are actually rather limiting. The earliest reservation time we could get for tomorrow was 7:15. We reserved dinner for 6:45 for a couple of nights later in the cruise. We don’t like this at all! On 15 cruises, I’ve never had one that didn’t allow my time dining until almost 7pm.

 

Back to our room to change for dinner, and Tara unpacked. I watched sail away party while she did that.

 

Sail away party:

 

20231104_163010.thumb.jpg.1e3e9c2b591402ebe87c4c953cfc06d0.jpg

 

Watched a parade/show in the promenade. Kinda weird.

 

 

Went to the Viking Crown lounge at top of ship for about 20 minutes while waiting for our Chops reservation time. No waiter came to us during that time. It’s a really nice lounge. Here is the view from there:

 

20231104_173120.thumb.jpg.2ad78d757e527238e7f4286235068022.jpg

 

 

Good and Bad

Arrived at Chops at 5:50 (6pm reservation time). It was not crowded. We got a nice table by the window. Service was hit and miss. Our waiter was very personable but there were a few issues. Small things but they sort of added up. It took about half an hour from the time we were seated until we got drinks. The bar seemed to have trouble with my daughter’s cocktail requests even though they were items listed on the Chops menu in the app.

 

Salad: I ordered the goat cheese salad that is supposed to have apple, cranberries and pecans. Mine came missing the apple. I asked to sub blue cheese for the goat cheese and this was done. Bacon appetizer was OK but not amazing. My daughter enjoyed the crab cake.

 

Filet mignon was disappointing. Was served at room temperature. I don’t know how long it was sitting before it came out to our table. We had the opposite problem on our last RC cruise. Is it that hard at a supposedly high end steakhouse to serve a properly cooked steak at the proper temperature? Yes, apparently it is. The filet was good, but I have definitely had better. Not really juicy. Chocolate cake was delicious! Very rich. Apple pie was very disappointing. Did not taste freshly baked. Crust was hard, not flaky. Dinner took approximately 2hrs 15 min. The steakhouse does not have upgraded glassware. Just the same very ordinary wine glasses as everywhere else on the ship. Carnival has (as of my last sailing) really nice larger glasses.

 

Apple salad missing the apple, with gorgonzola instead of the crispy goat cheese:

 

20231104_185036.thumb.jpg.5bc187e1d6d0cc81a3ab9b6769d5b514.jpg

 

 

Filet mignon

20231104_191434.thumb.jpg.6297e25062e6dda3b0d837bff4caa844.jpg

 

This dessert was really good

20231104_194858.thumb.jpg.41da761d10c8d08e09fc460178531d9c.jpg

 

The apple pie was just OK

 

20231104_194902.thumb.jpg.3f1b9eb6bb78d24600717a9b56f968af.jpg

  • Like 8
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good:

After dinner went to welcome aboard show. Very funny comedian, Steve McGrew. I really enjoyed the show.

 

Bad:

Then, casino. Very crowded, hard to move around. Seems small for this size of ship. Very busy. Very tight passing by slot machines, the bar, etc. Smoky. I was told by crew that only one corner of the casino is designated smoking, but it seemed like people were smoking everywhere – including a woman chain smoking at the video poker machines which are directly in front of the bar where staff should have noticed this. The pool area also was very smoky. Which seems kinda weird since this is an area where many kids are hanging out.

 

My favorite game is video poker. There are only 4 video poker machines. And $1 minimum. No 25 cent VP. I didn’t play. Lost a few bucks very fast on a penny slot and said no thanks. During several spins in the casino over the next few days, I never received waiter service. Had to go to the bar to order drinks.

 

Back to cabin. Can hear music from I guess Pig and whistle 2 decks below, at least until midnight. I don’t go to bed early so it wasn’t really bothersome but you might not like it if you are an early to bed person.

 

Sorry, I did a bad job of photos on this trip. I don't have any photos of the welcome aboard show or the casino.

  • Like 7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Day 2

I slept late. It was DST time change, we gained an hour. Daughter went to breakfast 8am, buffet was packed.

 

I did a brisk walk on deck 4, several laps over about 40 minutes. I had checked out the gym yesterday; it looked very small for this size ship. The weather was nice so I didn’t try to get a treadmill. Just walked outside.

 

Bad

Then we went to the solarium, which is poorly designed because the only way to get from the forward elevators to the main pool area and Windjammer is through the solarium. So you have lots of traffic including families and kids through the adult only area. The hot tubs were extremely crowded and the solarium area was very loud. Security came and asked one large group in the hot tub to tone it down. They were enjoying their cruise very much. The whole area was super noisy. Definitely not the “serenity” adult area we have experienced on Celebrity and Carnival.

 

Good

However it still is a nice space, quite a few loungers where you can look out at the ocean, some by the pool, two very large hot tubs, a bar that usually wasn’t too busy, and this is one of the few areas on the ship where we received waiter service.

 

Good

Lunch at Giovanni’s Table. Better deal than steakhouse and better service. Chicken piccatta was the best thing we had. Cheese board was excellent. Service from Michael was very good.

 

Cheese board appetizer

 

20231105_121103.thumb.jpg.dc6040ce7d5a7658808d9fc2656b9b4a.jpg

 

Chicken piccata, very good

 

20231105_123503.thumb.jpg.049138f072bb3c6c2954f505492e94b6.jpg

 

This is the fish, I think a Branzino? Don't remember for sure. Tara wasn't crazy about it.

 

20231105_123506.thumb.jpg.fdc7d53e3a87e4470ab44e9908f835ab.jpg

 

 

Desserts were really good

 

20231105_125615.thumb.jpg.a78daffdda50b09cb2d672b4568a5394.jpg

 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

After lunch I had a short unsuccessful spin in casino.

 

Bad

The earliest reservation we could get for dinner tonight was not until 7:15. This meant that we could not see the 8pm production show. We were seated at a table at the entrance. I mean, right at the entrance. With a nonstop stream of diners coming in and out right by the table. It was an awful location, I don’t even know why they would put tables that close to the entrance in a high traffic lane. We asked to be moved and they accommodated us, moving us to a table about 10 feet away.

 

Bad

The menu seems noticeably shorter than our last (and only other) RC cruise last year. Fewer options. I wish I had taken photos of the menus so I could be more specific and do a side by side comparison, but I’m sure that we had fewer options. The menus I saved from last year had about 10 appetizer options, including four rotating choices along with six “classics” such as french onion soup and escargots that were on the menu every night. The menus we saw on this cruise had only about six choices and no classics that were always available. For entrees, last year we had about 7 rotating choices each night in addition to two “classics,” salmon and NY strip. On this cruise that number was reduced to about seven total. Also, lobster was never available at no charge, not even in the steakhouse. This change in the menu was a huge fail IMO. I’m really sorry that the classics menu has disappeared. I’m sure this has been discussed extensively here but I haven’t been following this forum because we hadn’t planned an RC cruise until this one came up at the last minute.

 

There was a long wait for first course, then everything arrived at once. The food was not bad. Pretty typical MDR dining. Good but not amazing. Portion sizes were plenty.

 

Sorry, I'm not sure why some of my photos are showing up sideways or upside down.

 

French onion soup

 

20231105_194809.thumb.jpg.87752a160967dd67a2cac761e9f749a2.jpg

 

 

This is the cheese plate that is on the dessert menu. We ordered it for an appetizer.

 

20231105_194904.thumb.jpg.19a7489009205df53c5a34e866d70c58.jpg

 

 

Wedge salad

 

20231105_195158.thumb.jpg.1e8454fc900576e22dd5d87eabca3ef6.jpg

 

 

Beef tenderloin was good. I honestly think it compared favorably to the Chops filet mignon

20231105_200400.thumb.jpg.badbfc904c025754696e2c20bd9928d2.jpg

 

20231105_203446.thumb.jpg.173d18312d200f7a27bfa260473674ba.jpg

 

20231105_204319.thumb.jpg.d001d30eeb45abd435f2ec0504e13b40.jpg

 

  • Like 9
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bad

Due to our dining time we had to choose between the production show and the game shows. We picked the game shows. This is why we like to eat early when our port excursion times allow – so we have plenty of time for all the evening shows.

 

Good

We went to Finish That Lyric show and Perfect Couple show. Both were a ton of fun. Disappointed to miss the production show. We really liked all the game shows that we went to, led by the entertainment staff with passenger participation. As you can see, the participants were very enthusiastic -- as was the audience. 

 

20231105_221428.thumb.jpg.ee64ebfad18ceb2ba831639520350e49.jpg

 

20231105_221432.thumb.jpg.9fac604cae1b04840cf744bd5623d88d.jpg

 

20231105_221443.thumb.jpg.663a77482cd8a4cfa765ed842ff82b94.jpg

 

20231105_221913.thumb.jpg.464332f46ba4cb24ee6e592bc97cf633.jpg

 

 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Day 3 Costa Maya

 

Slept late again.

 

Good

Dining room opened early for lunch due to port time, so we went there at 11:00. Buffet wasn’t going to open until 11:45. Our excursion was scheduled for 12:15 so we needed an early lunch. We had a nice table by the window and were able to watch coming into port. I had a hamburger, daughter had caesar salad with chicken. Both were good, nothing really amazing. Service was excellent. While at lunch we noticed the waves looked really high and we were surprised we couldn’t feel the ship rocking more.

 

Went to the theater for our excursion at 12:15. A bit of a line to get off, scanned our cards and approached the gangway. A lady with a stroller was in front of me. She started to push the stroller on the gangway when a huge wave hit and washed over the gangway, missing her child in the stroller by inches. It was quite startling. We joked that she might be getting wet a little sooner than she bargained for, and we proceeded across the gangway. My daughter was right behind me.

 

As we crossed the gangway we heard voices behind us shouting at the passengers to stop. My daughter was literally the last person off the boat at that gangway. There were one or two other gangways open and they were all on walkie talkies, and all stopped debarkation. We proceeded down the pier with no one at all getting off after us. Debarkation had only been open for I think 10-15 minutes at this point, so not a ton of people off the ship yet. I don’t know how long debarkation was halted. We noticed a bunch of passengers arriving at the Beach Break about an hour after we arrived.

 

This video was taken later, when we got back on board.  The seas were still very rough, but I think a little less so than when we debarked. 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

We went down the pier to meet our excursion. We were first in line. Signed the waiver, waited about 20 minutes before being led to our bus. The pier was much less busy than normal, because of the delayed debarkation for many. We had the Beach Break with Open Bar excursion. It took about 10 minutes to get to the beach. We got loungers right at the water edge. The water was quite cloudy, much more so than the last time I was here. We swam a little, lounged around, checked our phones (which we have had in airplane mode for the last 2 days), had a couple of drinks. Called home while we have service.

 

We only stayed at the beach for about 2-3 hours. My daughter hated the unrelenting parade of people trying to get us to buy stuff. She just wanted to read her book but kept being interrupted every 60 seconds by someone selling bracelets or cigars or Hawaiian shirts or a kid trying to give us a “free” rose. Headed back to the ship when it started to lightly rain. Crammed into a minivan taxi with 7 of our new best friends. Quite a cozy ride.

 

Back on board we went back to our room to take turns showering. Went up to bar for a drink. Then went to deck 4 to watch pier runners. Amazed at how many people are just ambling back to the ship 15-20 minutes after 6:15 all aboard time.

 

Here are some pics from the beach

 

20231106_154631.thumb.jpg.df37937c2233c52438b1b46ab947e0a7.jpg

 

20231106_155812.thumb.jpg.7d53d0855aa5bae6782fb70a9b851e0a.jpg

 

20231106_155833.thumb.jpg.f8afb65c61bcb2c0769cdba272f1d96a.jpg

 

DSCN2143.thumb.JPG.8820bf9d569154d5abdb9aff2ff72054.JPG

 

DSCN2149.thumb.JPG.8da2d152b7fb29965f362cfffcff4f3f.JPG

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bad:

We had 6:45 “my time” dining reservations. As stated, we prefer to eat earlier. We have never encountered this late dining time on any other ship, and we don’t like it. We don’t do set time dining in case we have a late shore excursion or whatever, but we usually eat quite early so that we can spend the evening seeing the shows and doing other evening activities.

 

And even though it is “my time” dining, you still need to make a reservation (although there was a “no reservation” line). So there is really no flexibility at all.

 

So we go to the dining room and they try to seat us – again! – at the table right at the entrance. Are you kidding me?! I mean this dining room is huge and they are going to seat us at the table right at the entrance again? These tables are awful, IMO. There are about 4 of them that are directly at the entrance. Everyone going in and out is going to be going right past your table. That is not the dining experience I want. We asked for a different table and they moved us 10 feet away, to the exact table we had last night.

 

Look, I don’t want to be a Karen. But it doesn’t seem unreasonable to not want a constant parade of passengers brushing against you for your entire meal. I would be happy with virtually ANY other table in the dining room but this one at the entrance is ridiculous. I'm not sure how well my photo shows the problem. This is the table where they wanted to seat us. There was a nonstop stream of passengers directly behind it, and also coming from the other side. Photo taken from the table where they moved us.

 

20231106_195227.thumb.jpg.185fb86b026d7d02b02f95078f37a929.jpg

 

At the end or our meal, someone came and apologized. He said he will make sure we are not placed at the entrance next time, but will give us the same table 10 feet away. OK, that’s better than nothing. I appreciate that they are trying.

 

Dinner: strip steak was not bad – cooked to medium rare as requested, but was very thin. French onion soup and caesar salad were very good. Chocolate cake also was delicious.

 

20231106_195824.thumb.jpg.1efc95b5f96bdbccc624bccf822418a8.jpg

 

20231106_201658.thumb.jpg.e38547d79c48b1bf550e021c5001da41.jpg

 

20231106_204251.thumb.jpg.c2a687885687c918faaef1f60b4c2278.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good

We finished supper just in time to race over to the main theater. Saw Michael Holly, a comedy act. Very funny and entertaining. I really enjoy the shows. After this, we quickly went directly from the theater to Studio B, the ice rink, to see the show there. It was also very entertaining with great talent.

 

20231106_210421.thumb.jpg.b67e0e0ce59d14eb6d083af128c7a65f.jpg

 

20231106_214201.thumb.jpg.64f9dc408c27411318e9a67330ed30e1.jpg

 

20231106_214511.thumb.jpg.6f28c4a0819d60047bd9c4d2b906e6c2.jpg

 

20231106_222916.thumb.jpg.f67e0019a817e8b9a092cf0da32b93c3.jpg

 

20231106_223240.thumb.jpg.a7679680bb758e876e791f563212f8d4.jpg

 

 

We really enjoyed both shows. After, I went to the casino. I have not been impressed. As noted, it is very crowded, smoky, and they don’t have my game of choice (25cent video poker). But I decided to give it a shot.

 

The ugly  (not RC’s fault):

So I sat down at a slot machine. I had a drink that I had almost finished. It still had a sip or two. Some guy walks by, points to my drink, and says, “are you finished with that?” I was a little taken aback, this guy didn’t look like a waiter. I was like, what? He repeated, “are you finished with that?” I was so confused because why would some random dude be asking me this? Does he want my drink?!? So I sort of shrugged my shoulders, or something, I’m not sure what I said. And he says “OK because I can’t find anyplace to put this” – and he drops a cigarette in my glass!! Right in front of me on my slot machine!! And walks away.

 

I could not believe it. Are you serious?! Because there was still ice in my glass, the cigarette did not go out but sits on top of the ice, smoldering. After half a second of disbelief, I got up and went after the guy. With the glass. I said, “dude! You can take this with you. Do NOT leave a smoldering cigarette in front of me!” and I put the glass in his hand.

 

And just to be clear, we were not in the smoking section of the casino. Although the smoking area is not well defined and the smoke is noticeable everywhere. But still. This was the most dickish move I can ever remember.

 

Like I said, I don’t want to be a Karen. I’m sorry about the dining room seating; maybe that wouldn’t bother you but it did bother me. But this guy? Seriously?? Who the heck does that?

 

 

Anway, I'll be back tomorrow to finish this review. We have Cozumel coming up and then another sea day. 

Edited by luckybecky
  • Like 8
  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Every time I walk into the dining room and pass the tables by the door I tell myself I hope I never ever have one of those tables. 

 

The "bad" about the cigarette guy makes me madder than any of your other bads. 

 

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, SG65CB said:

Every time I walk into the dining room and pass the tables by the door I tell myself I hope I never ever have one of those tables. 

 

 

 

I'm glad it's not just me feeling that way about the entrance tables! 

 

12 hours ago, travelberlin said:

Thanks for your review! It is very detailed and well written. Could you please kindly give some more details of the cabin location? Is it very noisy? Are you still hearing music every night fr9m deck 5? What is in front of the cabin? What bars are below?

 

There were only cabins above and below. I always try to get a deck where we are sandwiched between other cabins, never with a bar or nightclub directly below, or buffet directly above. We never heard a peep from the cabins above, below, or to either side. The window did muffle the noise from the promenade (2 decks below), but was not completely soundproof. We could hear whenever there was music down there. This was pretty much every night apparently coming from the Pig and Whistle Pub which was below and to one side of us, usually up to around midnight.  Also on embarkation day there was a parade and dance performance in the early evening that we could hear from our cabin. 

 

11 hours ago, jean87510 said:

Great review.  I was on the Voyager out of San Juan last December and agree with your review of Chops. 

I'd personally just go to the Windjammer and get food at dinner.  Can you go to the later shows?

 

You're right, if we went to Windjammer we could make the shows. But we really enjoy the full service dining experience on board. If we could go to dinner before 6pm, we could make the early production show and then the later game shows. Most ships that we've been on do the "big" show in the theater twice each evening, usually 7-7:30pm, and again at 9 or 9:30. But not being able to start dinner until almost 7pm (or later) means we can't do that early show. We have not run into this scheduling issue on other ships. As long as we are back from excursions early enough, we can eat early and then make the early show, and the later game shows or comedy club as well. Oh well. First world problems, right?

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Day 4, Cozumel

 

The good:

Breakfast buffet was very good. I was really impressed by the omelet station. You order your omelet and they give you a pager so you don’t have to stand around waiting. This is a huge improvement that I have not seen on any ship. Because many people were already off the ship by the time we went, it didn’t take long at all to get my omelet and it was very good.

 

We have been to Cozumel before and didn’t plan an excursion. We got off the ship for only about an hour and walked around the shopping area. My daughter was very put off by the aggressiveness of the vendors. We didn’t stay long and got back on board.

 

The good:

Went to the Solarium which was very uncrowded. Tara got a clamshell and I had my choice of loungers. The hot tub wasn’t crowded at all, unlike other days, and things were quiet – also unlike other days when some groups were very loudly enjoying the hot tubs. We enjoyed this quiet time around the pool.

 

The bad:

Windjammer is completely closed when the buffet is closed. I don’t think I’ve ever seen this on any ship. Usually the seating area is open, and you can go in to get ice water or tea. I’ve often seen people using this area to read or play games even when the buffet is closed, but on this ship they close and lock the entry doors so you can’t go in.

 

Bad: Music from the promenade was very loud on 70s night in our room. It ended shortly after 11pm. If you are an early to bed person, this could really be bothersome. How did people know about 70s night? Many passengers dressed in 70s garb. We had no idea about this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good:

Izumi was our best meal so far. I had yaki udon noodles with beef, excellent. Pork dumplings were delicious. Tara had Tonkotsu ramen and it was very good. Also the crispy rice spicy tuna, and truffled creamy losbster tempura roll. Everything was very good and service was excellent. I don’t like sushi but there was plenty for me to eat here.

 

20231107_185517.thumb.jpg.c01d2a1816e5c5fb8cbdbcd2821aedb2.jpg

 

20231107_191626.thumb.jpg.7df36b8da66c62ba84e9aa6fdff1f8bc.jpg

 

20231107_191635.thumb.jpg.299f3237498adad1efb171aed64020c6.jpg

 

20231107_193009.thumb.jpg.37c12a27155fa1ca70986b5e696fc8dc.jpg

 

20231107_193024.thumb.jpg.c39959d7a4b6882831ac40f5123108bc.jpg

 

 

 

20231107_193029.thumb.jpg.2cd8faee81069bac0bbace1813e4b4f0.jpg

 

20231107_193033.thumb.jpg.918674df52071c69d2e23dd80c12947b.jpg

 

20231107_200513.thumb.jpg.f770849cc459a4c927bb8c8d0497a03f.jpg

 

Meh:

The production show was disappointing. Just a hodgepodge of songs. I stayed for most of it but left a little early. The performers were great, I just felt that the show itself wasn’t that exciting. I know, I know. I've carried on about how much I want to see all the shows and then I complain that I didn't like this one. Sorry.  😳  But the Majority Rules game show was fun.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Day 5

We had a very lazy day. The pools and hot tubs were so crowded. We didn’t even try that. Especially after the raucous behavior we’ve seen in the past few days in the Solarium hot tubs. On some ships (many) the adult areas are more quiet zones (even called “Serenity” areas) --- but they are nothing like serene on this ship except during port times.

 

There weren’t a lot of activities we were interested in. The usual trivia and bingo. If you are into the rock climbing or flow rider, this would be a good time to do those. We didn’t try them. We packed in the afternoon, hit the casino, took a nap, read a book. Just generally took it easy. Went up to the helicopter pad and took pictures of the sunset.

 

Lunch in the buffet. Windjammer is a very typical cruise buffet IMO. Nothing that stands out (except the omelet station as already mentioned). The only other free options for lunch are the dining room, and pizza on the promenade. They also serve a very limited selection of sandwiches and desserts there. We missed Guy’s Burgers and Blue Iguana cantina from Carnival which serve food made fresh to order.

 

The bad

Staff were not as friendly as on other ships. This was really quite noticeable to me. On many ships, we have had bar waiters learn our names and drink preferences on day one, or just crew in general being very friendly and helpful. Greeting us, asking how our day was, that kind of thing. On this ship, we experienced much less of that. Nobody was rude, they just seemed all business. It was actually quite striking, compared to our past cruising experience. Also bartenders on other ships are like whirling dervishes, pumping out drinks at high speed. Not so much here. My daughter wondered if maybe there have been staff cutbacks, resulting in poor morale.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The good:

Our assistant waiter Soma in the dining room was one exception. He was very cheery and helpful – and by the way he is going home tomorrow after 7 months on board. Maybe that explains his happy mood. Our room steward was also very nice and greeted us by name, but we only saw him occasionally and didn’t really have much interaction. (By the way, we got only 2 very simple towel animals on this 5 day cruise. Not a big deal to us but I know some people enjoy these.) In general, I would say everyone was just doing their job but I didn’t get the friendly, personal vibe I have had on other ships.

 

The cruise director was not as animated and ever-present as some others we have met. He didn’t really make much of an impression on us.

 

Good:

Battle of the Sexes show was hilarious. Go early to get a good seat. Afterwards, we saw Steve McGrew again. Another great show. We really enjoyed these.

 

20231108_213509.thumb.jpg.c8965cbb7322794fd41ed9f2e6382a02.jpg

 

20231108_213514.thumb.jpg.c6568ee1b71653d3ac2a25b198098be3.jpg

 

20231108_214319.thumb.jpg.7a3f42cf4f92576bb6fcf80ef1d44f06.jpg

 

 

20231108_213509.thumb.jpg.c8965cbb7322794fd41ed9f2e6382a02.jpg

 

20231108_223121.thumb.jpg.41941a8e0b510e0bd077e1e0d24f0d3b.jpg

 

Edited by luckybecky
Link to comment
Share on other sites

We had a beautiful sunset for our last night. The helicopter pad is a great place for watching sunsets, pier runners, or port arrivals.

 

20231108_182726.thumb.jpg.0c0d1f7f05b5bdd557b1027fcdf947b4.jpg

 

Here are some pics from supper. Sorry some are loading upside down again. 

 

Beef carpaccio

 

20231108_202116.thumb.jpg.902c33f80c03922367c0ba62c893d09f.jpg

 

Chicken parmesan. Our waiter brought a very generous portion of shredded parmesan to sprinkle on top. 

 

20231108_203612.thumb.jpg.e06d55f10563367d9ed3bf1515ef1b85.jpg

 

I asked for a small side of broccoli or any vegetable to go with my chicken parm. I got a whole plateful!

 

20231108_203614.thumb.jpg.6d2bab1e08bc2616caee8e64f6c8ede4.jpg

 

I think this was a lemon tart.

 

20231108_205930.thumb.jpg.4d992f9239e9962358110ceacb345d63.jpg

20231108_201801.jpg

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Day 6 Debarkation

 

We woke up at 7am. We were already fully packed. We dressed quickly, tossed a few last items in our suitcases and ready to go before 7:30. We kept waiting for announcements. Every other ship I’ve ever been on is making frequent, loud announcements, trying to keep the process moving efficiently. At the bare minimum, they usually announce when the ship has been cleared and debarkation is officially open.

 

Bad

Radio silence. Finally a few minutes before 8:00, I suggested we just head out even though there had been no announcement and the feed on the TV had not indicated that debarkation had begun.

 

As expected, a madhouse. Forget getting an elevator. We expected that and were prepared to carry our luggage down the stairs. Joined the line which snaked from the elevators through the dining room to the outside deck and around the back.

 

Good

Once we reached the terminal, it was a very fast and easy process. Facial recognition only, no passport check or customs or anything. Took about 45 minutes to get from our cabin, to off the ship and in our car.

 

Overall, we had a good time. As I said before, we never let small concerns ruin our vacation. I’ve made numerous comparisons to our past cruise experiences and I don’t think this particular cruise compared particularly well. However on the positive side this was the best inside cabin we have ever had.

 

I know that some people disparagingly refer to Carnival as “the Walmart of the Seas.” Well, truth be told, I think Carnival is doing a better job for cruises out of Galveston in terms of dining and entertainment. The steakhouse and production shows have definitely been better on Carnival. And this cruise did not compare favorably to our only other RC cruise on the Brilliance of the Seas. I’m sorry, RC loyalists. These are just my opinions. I’m interested to hear what others think about all this. But we still are grateful that we have the opportunity to cruise. There’s always good and bad on every vacation, some things are great and sometimes things can go sideways. It’s OK. We enjoy ourselves no matter what.

 

Thanks for following along. Happy cruising!

  • Like 6
  • Thanks 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, luckybecky said:

Day 6 Debarkation

 

We woke up at 7am. We were already fully packed. We dressed quickly, tossed a few last items in our suitcases and ready to go before 7:30. We kept waiting for announcements. Every other ship I’ve ever been on is making frequent, loud announcements, trying to keep the process moving efficiently. At the bare minimum, they usually announce when the ship has been cleared and debarkation is officially open.

 

Bad

Radio silence. Finally a few minutes before 8:00, I suggested we just head out even though there had been no announcement and the feed on the TV had not indicated that debarkation had begun.

 

As expected, a madhouse. Forget getting an elevator. We expected that and were prepared to carry our luggage down the stairs. Joined the line which snaked from the elevators through the dining room to the outside deck and around the back.

 

Good

Once we reached the terminal, it was a very fast and easy process. Facial recognition only, no passport check or customs or anything. Took about 45 minutes to get from our cabin, to off the ship and in our car.

 

Overall, we had a good time. As I said before, we never let small concerns ruin our vacation. I’ve made numerous comparisons to our past cruise experiences and I don’t think this particular cruise compared particularly well. However on the positive side this was the best inside cabin we have ever had.

 

I know that some people disparagingly refer to Carnival as “the Walmart of the Seas.” Well, truth be told, I think Carnival is doing a better job for cruises out of Galveston in terms of dining and entertainment. The steakhouse and production shows have definitely been better on Carnival. And this cruise did not compare favorably to our only other RC cruise on the Brilliance of the Seas. I’m sorry, RC loyalists. These are just my opinions. I’m interested to hear what others think about all this. But we still are grateful that we have the opportunity to cruise. There’s always good and bad on every vacation, some things are great and sometimes things can go sideways. It’s OK. We enjoy ourselves no matter what.

 

Thanks for following along. Happy cruising!

I think this was a very fair review and I enjoyed reading. I know many people like leisurely meals but 2+ hrs at Chops is way too long to me. That mother/daughter time must have been very nice!

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, fla33023 said:

I think this was a very fair review and I enjoyed reading. I know many people like leisurely meals but 2+ hrs at Chops is way too long to me. That mother/daughter time must have been very nice!

 

Yes, it was nice! My daughter is a great travel buddy. We've done several trips together. 

 

I agree about the time at Chops. I checked the time on my photos to make sure I was right about that. As mentioned, it took half an hour just to get drinks. Apps arrived at 6:34pm, almost 45 minutes after we were seated. Entrees at 7:14pm, another 40 minutes later. We had arrived at the restaurant at 5:50pm, so that's a long time to get the entree on the table. Dessert came at 7:48pm so almost 2 full hours to the minute. By the time we finished dessert we had been there about 2 1/4 hours. That is a long time. I don't like being rushed through a meal, but this was too long even for me. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for all the info. Doing this cruise in Feb, directly after returning from the same itinerary on Carnival Breeze. I’m looking forward to what the differences will be. My daughter and I have also gone on a few trips with just the two of us. Always a great time to share and make memories.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
 Share

  • Forum Jump
    • Categories
      • Welcome to Cruise Critic
      • New Cruisers
      • Cruise Lines “A – O”
      • Cruise Lines “P – Z”
      • River Cruising
      • ROLL CALLS
      • Cruise Critic News & Features
      • Digital Photography & Cruise Technology
      • Special Interest Cruising
      • Cruise Discussion Topics
      • UK Cruising
      • Australia & New Zealand Cruisers
      • Canadian Cruisers
      • North American Homeports
      • Ports of Call
      • Cruise Conversations
×
×
  • Create New...