I have cruised regularly since the start up. It was really noticeable in the beginning, but the ships were half full. It has gotten better, but our cruise on Celebration (school break week) it was not good (bar service). So much so, that I sent a love note to some Carnival mgt friends (which prompted calls to discuss our dissatisfaction. We will be on her again on 8/10, I will be posting live and can give you further updates then.