Schmoe38

John I believe this may have been the Super Tuscan that Charla enjoyed. Poggio Al Tesoro Bolgheri Superiore Sondraia 2018

Generally, the difference in pricing between a Royal Suite and Penthouse suite runs about $3,500/person. Remember, there is just 1 Penthouse Suite on Reflection, so, depending on how serious you are about getting the Penthouse, if you are going to make a Move Up bid, give it your best shot and don’t look for a low ball offer to be successful. That is not to say that low balls are not successful, it’s just, with 1 stateroom on the block, your chances at being successful on a low offer are lessened. Randy

We use a 1-877 number from Canada and it is always answered with minimal delay. We typically stay in suites and this Zenith number does not appear to have been merged with the Retreat number. Randy

If the Martini Bar is a “must see” for you, the best time to try the martinis and have some breathing room is, close to opening hour (except embarkation day) Depending on the day, that time can range from 2pm to 4pm. You’ll miss some of the flair of the more crowded times, but you will still get some shows during these off hours. Good Luck Randy

Hi Trish It’s the Nov 10-20/25 Summit sailing. That would really be neat, but unfortunately both PHs are occupied. Would Eclipse Nov 16-25/24 interest you? We are in a RS on that one. The PH next to us is currently open. Randy

John We would so dearly like to sail with you again. Our focus, fortunately or unfortunately is away from the e-Class ships, as they do not really strike the right tone for us. Nothing against them…just a preference, for us, to the S-Class and M-Class ships. Our next 3 sailings are on Eclipse in Nov 2024, Reflection in March 2025 and Summit in November 2025. Fingers crossed that our paths will cross again in the not too distant future. Randy and Connie

There’s an All Star Cast giving you valuable information here. Hope you have enough to make the decision that is sensible for you. Randy

The longer you wait while getting feedback from us, the more at risk you are to having someone else grab this stateroom ahead of you. Book it…you will not be sorry. Randy

Very likely. They are bringing you a selection that they feel you might enjoy. If you do, the bottle will get emptied at your table. Remember, the bottle that comes to you, will not be all that expensive. If you don’t enjoy it, there’s a good chance someone else in the restaurant will show an interest. There have been instances where the recommended wine does not sit right with us, but I have to say, those instances have been in the minority. The prices of wine by the glass options in the Premium Beverage Package will probably never make sense to us when we are comparing overall value vs what we can pay for that same bottle retail. We just put that comparable process on the back burner and look more to the “do I, or don’t I enjoy it.” Randy

John Don’t be concerned with what you are seeing or not seeing on the app or wine lists. The challenge we have noticed in Luminae is whether or not your sommelier is willing to be a little “adventurous”. We appreciate they are stretched for time, but have found many really want to show what they can do for you. We’ve found that when we tell the sommelier what we are having, or planning to have, for our main entree, he/she is, often times, more than willing to offer their suggestions for a wine option. One extra suggestion…we ask them to go to the deepest, darkest corner of the wine cellar to find a selection, by the glass, that is not on the every day Premium Beverage Package list. If you are prepared to pay an upcharge, be sure to mention that, and then, there’s a bit more flexibility. We have been able to enjoy some wines that we have never tasted before, yet are a pleasure to drink. We could care less if the selected bottle costs $16.99, or less, retail. It’s more of an appreciation for the effort put forward, rather than just going by the script. This doesn’t always work, but if you don’t ask…you don’t get. Enjoy your upcoming cruise Randy

Thanks so much for your comments regarding the Penthouse Suite on Reflection vs the Reflection Suite. We booked a cruise on Reflection in March 2025 and had a decision to make. The Penthouse and Reflection Suite were both available at the time of booking. We had been in the Penthouse before, but had never been in the Reflection Suite. We went back and forth and decided to go with the Penthouse. We liked the PH location on the ship vs the forward bias of the Reflection Suite. We like the balcony on the PH better as well. We’re actually comfortable with our decision. The only downside to this decision was the process itself. Since there is only 1 PH on Reflection, you can’t “hum and hah” too long or someone else may make the decision for you, by booking it ahead of you. If we had chosen the Reflection Suite, it would have just been my luck that when I was using that unique shower, the privacy setting would have been Out of Order, without my knowledge. Randy

Hi Trish Thank you for being our neighbours on one of those sailings. We, to this day still talk about the wonderful time we had while sailing with you along the Pacific Coast in those spectacular M Class Penthouses. Hope to sail with you again some day. Randy and Connie

We also use the $US Dollar Visa card from RBC and have for years. The fee is only USD$65 per year and that’s it. We also maintain a $USD bank account to facilitate the payment of any outstanding credit card balances. With the fluctuating Canadian Dollar, we are able to take advantage of any strength by purchasing US Dollars along the way and building up account balances to prepare, as best as we can, for any and all upcoming cruises. We are not concerned with the rate of return on the bank account, but rather, reducing the risk of having to purchase a lump sum of US Dollars just before final payment on any cruise. Our last major USD purchase for the bank account was when the $CAD was .85USD. So far, we’re good till the end of 2025. This works for us. Randy

Kelly If you have Fine Cut Steakhouse on your agenda, you are in for a treat. We were there last night and we had an exceptional evening. Our friend had the bone in filet mignon and he said it was the best cut of meat he has ever had…and he’s had many a filet. My rib eye was a very close second. We were privileged to be part of the wonderful food service. Ricaldo, our waiter and Glen, our sommelier raised the bar to new heights. Thank you Fine Cut! We enjoyed it so much, we booked an additional visit. Kelly, we really haven’t seen you flying around the ship since day one. You certainly have the best hiding places. Enjoy the remainder of your time on board. Randy

Kelly Travel Safely

Sorry to hear you have lost the love for St Maarten. We have always, and continue to look forward to visiting this island. Eventhough we may go through similar travels each time we visit, we continue to have a soft spot for the people of St Maarten, and the memories that have been created each time we are there.

Hi Linda We are fortunate to be sailing with PinkSandGirl on this itinerary. We will get a chance to meet each other face to face on the Pre-Sailaway get together. Hope she still talks to us at the end of the cruise. Randy

Will this help?

We typically cruise in the Retreat and have been watching Retreat pricing for a while, and even now, pricing is through the roof. The Retreat pricing on this itinerary is way more reasonable. Randy

It’s unfortunate conflicting information is shared in telephone calls. Butlers are still advertised for Celebrity Suites and I see nothing in the newsletter that would suggest otherwise. We have always viewed the mini fridge as offside whenever we were in a suite lower than a Royal Suite, so no big deal to us. It’s going to be a marketing nightmare for Celebrity to announce the return of butlers to Sky Suites only to have a change of heart and continue with the Retreat Team. Too many marketing nightmares can shorten the career of a President very quickly. It might take some time to implement the butlers back to Sky Suites shipwide, but that seems to be a trend (eg-the single supplement pricing vs double occupant pricing for the same stateroom is still not fixed on line). That single supplement overcharge marketing blunder was formally rescinded a while back. I think it’s fair to say that changes (both good and bad) are a part of life in everything we do. Celebrity’s challenge is ensuring these changes are implemented and applied on a consistent basis shipwide. So far, that has proven to be a challenge that has not yet been conquered. Randy

Here’s an alternative that works as often as it doesn’t work….. Early in the cruise, (not the first day, as it is generally more chaotic) speak with your sommelier and ask him/her what bottled wine you can get by the glass. Tell them you don’t mind paying an upcharge per glass. You need to get a handle on whether or not they are flexible or “by the book.” My suggestion is to first, have a look at the wines by the bottle list, and focus on those in the $60-$70(ish) price range. The reason I am suggesting this range is as follows…the premium beverage package covers wine up to $17/glass. If you factor in 4 glasses per bottle, you come in at $68. I wouldn’t suggest you press your luck on the more expensive wines. The fact that you are in an Edge Villa will help a bit, but is not a slam dunk in your favour. If your sommelier is not open to this alternative, please don’t push, as the Celebrity staff work hard enough and you don’t want to be one of those people who enjoy causing a scene. Remember, if you don’t ask…you’ll never know. Randy Randy

It’s our understanding that her existing contract ends April 22/24. That doesn’t necessarily mean she leaves the ship that day, as unforeseen circumstances could arise that might extend the time needed to have her at the helm.

We use Flights by Celebrity all the time, to Ft Lauderdale leaving through Toronto or Detroit. We live in London, Ontario. We’ve never really found a major difference in pricing vs the actual airline, but we have had 2 instances where prices had declined since our original booking, and as there are no fees to make changes prior to final payment, we were able to take advantage. One of the difficulties we have had personally is when we fly with Westjet. We can book the seats on line prior to final payment when we book with Air Canada, but we have to have the Flights by Celebrity agent book the seats prior to final payment, when we book with Westjet. We have traditionally flown first class to Ft Lauderdale from Toronto or Detroit. One of the advantages of booking Westjet from Toronto is, they have no first class section. Their “front of the plane” section is actually considered Premium Economy and as such, is more attractively priced vs Air Canada’s First Class. Just an option. Randy

There’s no guarantee on any of the comments here, but often times, the Captains operate on a 3 months on and 3 months off rotation, The fact that Captain Kate was on vacation over the Christmas holiday period would suggest there is a really good chance she will be at the helm in April 2024. The February/March sailings may also be in play depending on the start date of her current vacation.

This is definitely a Celebrity issue. The charge would have been levied at the “sell” US currency rate to the client and then the correction would have been levied at the “buy” US currency from the client. There is a spread in those 2 exchange rates, the sell being the higher. As this charge was done in error by Celebrity, they owe you the $$ difference on the charge amount times the difference in the two exchange rates. I know the principle of the matter is on your side. Just remember, your time and effort is worth something, probably more than the dollar amount involved and the principle, but I get it. Good Luck Randy