I've done the Breakaway twice, the Getaway and the Joy, all out of NY and to me, except for the Observation Lounge on the Joy and the different shows, they are all the same ship. Crowded atrium and very few places to sit.
In October we did MSC Meraviglia and February we did Carnival Venezia also out of NY area, just to try different ships. Wasn't crazy about MSC but they had great shows and tons of places to sit and relax. We surprisingly enjoyed Carnival but their shows were meh but their food was good and good venues and places to sit and relax.