When we sailed on HAL we would go to the buffet when it opened in the evenings just to see the MDR entrees for that night, made it easier to decide what to order in the MDR. After sailing last summer on the HAL Oosterdam following our Reflection cruise, I would have to agree with your food comment. I can honestly say the Oosterdam MDR food, overall was better than the food in the Reflection Luminae. We had for the first time, more misses than hits in Luminae. Fortunately, the food isn't the main reason we cruise Celebrity, the Retreat overall is a much better experience than the suites on HAL. We have two cruises this year in Sky Suites on Equinox and Apex, if the food is no better than the Reflection last year, we may be rethinking our two Edge cruises in 2024 and looking at Viking or Oceania.