I remember my first or 2nd cruise on X in 2014/2015. We did a gally tour( free) and the Food and Beverage director said that X spends more per passenger on food than other lines in the same class. I don't think they could say the same now.
We were on Reflection in September( I blogged it). It was our first Suite experience on X. Desserts in Luminae were better than AQ desserts and much better than OV. The food was good, not mind blowing, but good. Sadly, I saw a lot of the cuts in OVC. We've deflected over to Oceania. We had a wonderful experience a year go on our first Oceania cruise. The food was so much better, I loved the small less crowded ships. We do have 1 more X cruise booked for Great barrier reef( 2024) because the price was great and it is on the Edge. Coincidentally, after that cruise, we'll finally reach Elite status.