!!! BREAKAWAY !!! To Bermuda ^_^ Our Ultimate Review and Complete Pictorial Guide!

[qvenedandan]

Gambee - Just partially finished watching the videos (two more parts to go). I really love the visual tour of the ship (and with your narrative, bonus!) Bravo to you taking outdoor videos while it's so windy.

 

It has been my very first time following a thread (over 70 pages)! I am sure not being the only person to ask, but you should seriously think of being a cruise reviewer/critic as a full-time job. Well done!

[gambee]

thank you for all the comments, I will address them later. I just need sometime to relax :).

 

[qvenedandan]

Gambee - Yes, it's me again. ;) Now I am up to page 74...

 

By any chance you know if there's the "chocolate buffet" - all different types of chocolate desserts, chocolate fondue, sculptures made out of chocolate - on the Breakaway? So far I don't see that being "advertised" on the Daily... Thanks again for your help!

[CruiseIreland]

thank you for all the comments, I will address them later. I just need sometime to relax :).

 

You deserve the rest Gambee, and an award. Another great review. Looking forward to your Carnival cruise. In the meantime, I will just have to make do with others' merely excellent reviews! THANK YOU:),Ken.

[shoelover536]

Thank you for your comparison! I also liked it how you break down the scores into categories. For example, X and RCL score very highly in categories that are important to me (food, service, entainment, bars)...and less well (X in particular) in areas that I could care less about (internet speed, cabin TV). Love the way you did this so people can look at what they think is important and see how you felt each line did in that category.

 

Looking forward to your next review! :D

[pcreek]

Gambee - your review was absolutely amazing! I think it's time for you to take another cruise - just to relax! thanks for all the hard work you did here...it was obviously appreciated by many! :)

 

Thanks for posting this photo - you are correct - it looks perfect in your collection! :D

 

And also to pcreek for sending me that amazing Breakaway Coin. Thank you. I have a full collection now =)

 

[uncleboo]

hi what is your facebook name?

what does Gambee stand for?:p

[brian99]

Let me be the 100th person to say that was an awesome review. :D

 

It would be great if you could make your review into a PDF so we could read it start to finish without having to scroll through 1500+ posts.

[Tom-n-Cheryl]

Let me be the 100th person to say that was an awesome review. :D

 

...

 

You might be late on that... ;):D

 

Tom

[Weeziblu]

Thank you thank you thank you thank you thank you!!!!

 

I have soooo enjoyed joining you! Your review was spectacular and has me looking MORE forward than ever to my November voyage! I'll admit, I"m a little sad that the review has ended!

[Cruiser_190]

 

RCCL, X and NCL Comparison

 

 

 

I will try now to fairly compare all my past cruises to each other.

 

Also keep into account my age. I am sure this will play a big factor in this comparison.

 

I am highlighting the old info in red. I simply copied it from my Silli review.

 

I will be basing the scores from 1 to 5.

 

1. Poor

2. Average

3. Good

4. Great

5. Excellent

 

 

Food:

 

RCCL: 3.5

X : 4

NCL : 4

 

So why am I scoring Breakaway higher than the Allure? Well that can easily be answered by saying that since I never visited the MDR for dinner, then automatically Breakaway wins. But that is not at all my reasoning.

 

While the food on the Allure was overall good, there was nothing that really stood out to me other than the steak at Chops. Everything else was tasty, but mainly, the biggest problem was that the food was not as hot as I would have wanted it to be.

 

Here is why Breakaway wins. I simply love the amount of alternatives that they offer. I absolutely loved their food bars, and the best part of it is that they don't charge a cover fee plus a la cart pricing (like the sushi place does in the Allure, which was a real turnoff for me).

 

In addition to that, I don't think I had one luke warm meal on the Breakaway. Everything was nice and hot. Even the room service was really good on the Breakaway.

 

The only bad meal we had was in La Cucina, and I don't think I will go back there again. I would however love to try Moderno, Chops and Blue in my next NCL cruise.

 

The only reason I can't score NCL with say a 4.5, is because it just simply does not compare to the Silli food. X is leading strongly in this category.

 

The food aboard the Allure was for the most part good, the main issue with the Allure was that most of the food came to the table warm and not hot. This was never an issue X, the food was always nice and hot. The buffet of the Allure was good and had good selections, but on the Silli there were much more choices and again everything was kept very hot and rotated frequently. Also the main restaurant on the Allure 150 was not up to par to Murano by no means. The two Dover Soles were in complete extremes, the one in the Allure was cold and fishy and the one in Murano was just PERFECT.

 

X was very close on getting a perfect score, but like everything there were flaws.

That first night when I got room service, the food was just very bad…

The chicken saltinboca on the MDR was not chicken saltinboca and it was really dry.

The cupcakes on Qsine, were TERRIBLE.

Mom's risotto on Tuscan was very salty.

 

But that is it, most of the food was outstanding. The price of the specialty dinning also comes into play, I honestly think X is charging too much for these venues. I was happy that I got the package and lowered the cost of them slightly. On the Allure specialty venues are better priced and that makes them more attractive.

 

Room service arrives really nice and hot in X (breakfast), again in Allure not so much. I believe I mentioned that is why decided to go more often to the buffet on the Allure.

 

 

 

Cabin

 

RCCL: 4

X : 4

NCL : 3.7

 

 

You might all be wondering why I scored the cabin lower than my other two cruises. Well, I am trying to be fair and actually accounting the size of the average balcony of Breakaway into this category. Sure, if I was counting the size of the balcony we had on this cruise it would be close to 5, but I want to be fair and judge the room that matches the other two rooms.

 

Overall the room is very well laid out, with my only issue was with the lack of storage. Another thing to note is that I do not like the new system that deactivates all the power outlets in the room if the card is not inside it. But that is an easy fix with the dummy card that they give you to put in there.

 

The room itself looked more modern than the X and RCCL rooms, and that is why I am not giving it a lower score.

 

The average size of the balcony in this ship is a real shame; I ponder why they made the decision to do them so small. I would dare say that I would seriously consider getting an inside room instead of a balcony on my next cruise. Unless of course I can afford another aft room, in which case you will be in paradise.

 

 

I believe that the cabin on X is 12 sq feet larger than the RCCL cabin, but for some reason the X cabin felt like it lacked storage. One thing that I also miss from the Allure was the balcony light, I like working on my computer at night and I really missed that light. The bathrooms are both good but I think the shower on the X ship is a little bit larger than the Allure. I think scoring them both with a 4 is a good thing, please know that I have never traveled suite so I am just happy scoring up to balcony for now ;).

 

 

 

Cabin TV system

 

RCCL: 4.5

X : 2.5

NCL : 3.5

 

There are two reasons why NCL scores lower here.

 

1. I really like how the Allure offers the option of placing your room service orders via the TV system. Not only that, but you're also able to order breakfast that same morning. NCL does not offer that.

 

2. The TV programming is just pathetic. Old movies, very few TV shows in their rotating TV show channel, and a bunch of international news channels. They really need to up their game here and include more channels.

 

I remember the Allure offered a bunch of newer movies for free, in NCL all of the newer movies were Pay-Per-View. Although that is kind of the overall feel of the ship… if you want something, you will pay extra for it.

 

Aside from that I would like to say that the TV system is very fast, and extremely easy to use, unlike X. All they need is to add a few more channels and let you order from the TV and they would have a winning system in my book.

 

 

The TV system on the Allure was magical, it was so easy to use and it had all the information you could ever need. Including menus, shows, shore excursions and more. Even more than that, was the fact that it was so easy to navigate and use, placing orders was super simple.

 

In contrast X system is full of bugs and lacks all the information that the Allure one had. Add to that how complicated it is to place orders or activate the internet and you end up with a very lousy system.

 

Not to mention that we kept constantly loosing signal with the TV programing.

 

Sorry X you need to step up your game…

 

 

 

Internet

 

RCCL: 4

X : 2.5

NCL: 3.8

 

I would dare to say that the internet is almost the same as the Allure, but the only problem is that at times it does slow down. Also keep in mind that the logout screen at times wouldn’t load. So all you have to do is type www dot logout dot com and you will log out.

 

 

You all heard me complain about the internet and trust me it was pretty bad, even Bugsy experienced that in his voyage. The internet of the Allure was very good for the most part, if I recall correctly we lost internet on one day for a few hours. I am not sure if the Silli is having issues with their system, but it definitely needs improvement.

 

 

 

Pools & Jacuzzi

 

RCCL: 4

X : 4

NCL : 3.7

 

I am not really sure how to score this ship here. The thing is that I honestly don't think that there are enough pools and jacuzzis for the amount of people in this ship. However, in our voyage it was not bad at all. I always had room in the jacuzzi when I wanted to be in there and there was always room in the pools as well.

 

I am not sure if with better weather it might be much more crowded or not, but overall I found it to be adequate for out voyage. By the way, we were sailing at about 70-80% capacity.

 

So with little hesitation I will dare to give this ship a 3.8 in this area. I wonder if my opinion will change once I try Getaway in the summer in Florida. Only time will tell.

 

The one thing that does bother me a little is that NCL has a tendency to charge for everything, and it follows for Vibe. That would be free space on RCCL and X, plus they both offer the solariums that NCL lacks.

 

 

At first I was very worried that with only 6 Jacuzzis we would have problem finding space in them. But don't ask me how the two in the solarium always had space for us. Also the pool in the solarium in X is much larger than the the one on the Allure. In contrast the Allure has about 12 Jacuzzis and and 5 pools, which is enough for everyone on board. I can honestly say that ratio based both ships are able to supply their guest with enough water time to make you happy.

 

 

 

 

 

I will deduct this from the totals, since NCL does not have one, and I will not take points away from NCL for not having one.

 

 

 

 

I will split the Entertainment into two categories, activities and shows. This will make it more fair for the Silli.

 

Activities

 

RCCL : 5

X : 2.5

NCL : 5

 

Honestly I am not sure what to say, if you get bored in this ship, well… There is simply so much to do at all times, that it compares completely with the Allure. NCL might even offer more game shows than the Allure, but overall they are both up to par.

 

They are both very fun ships!

 

 

 

Ok so I mean really, who has a zip line in a ship, who? who? The Allure does :D, not to mention the rock climbing wall, Flow Riders, Ice skating, carrousel ect. The Silli is rather limited in this aspect with very little in the ways of that, I think they have the basketball court and the events that they held by the pool area. It is a rather tame ship.

 

 

 

Shows

 

RCCL : 4.5

X : 4

NCL: 4

 

I won’t say much here since you know I am not one for shows. But I will explain why RCCL is still leading. It is simply because of the Aqua Theater. I mean reallym how can you match the Aqua show???

 

 

 

I am not much of show kind of person, but in this regard I am giving the edge to the Allure simply because they have a Broadway show and a diving show in its very own theater. Add to that the ice show and you have a great deal of possibilities. The Silli has good shows with good performers, but there were a few things that I did not like.

 

A little something to note is that the A cappella group on the Silli was horrible compared to the Allure one (please remember I hate A cappella groups) so that must say something in itself.

 

I did however enjoy myself on the Silli watching the comedy shows, those are my favorites :).

 

 

 

Bars

 

RCCL : 3.5

X : 4.7

NCL : 3.5

 

The bars are about the same in the Allure and Breakaway, but nothing stood out like it did in the Silli cruise. So I think this is a fair score for this ship.

 

 

 

While the Allure does have the raising tides bar, it is simply no match for the Martini bar in the Silli. The Silli hands down wins this section, I absolute love that bar. The molecular was fine and all, but I wasn't really crazy about their drinks and they are so complex and take time to make. Gambee has no patience when I am waiting for a drink. Now imagine the entreatment factor of the martini bar combined with the rising tides bar :D. lol. Never mind to much wait waiting for bar to get there, I want my drink!

 

Also the sunset bar was very nice, I guess it is similar to the wipeout bar on the Allure. But the sunset had a much better vibe.

 

 

 

Elegance

 

RCCL : 3.5

X : 4.5

NCL : 4.7

 

WOW! Breakaway is stunning, the Allure has nothing on this ship as terms of crisp elegance. Why am I scoring it slightly higher than the Silly? Well, I thought they made excellent use of LED lights throughout the ship. And that alone sets it apart.

 

I loved the decor of this ship. NCL did an amazing job with it!

 

 

 

The S ships are among the cleanest looking ships at sea, actually I think they are my favorite ones. The same line concept follows around throughout the ship, the Allure just doesn't have that. Like I said the S class almost feels like the W Hotel and I not quite sure how to compare the Allure, maybe to a Hilton?

 

 

 

Lawn/central Park/Water Front (special ship Feature)

 

RCCL : 4.5

X : 4

NCL: 4.7

 

I am surprised NCL is the first line to come up with this concept, and they have a true winner in my book. After how Epic was so enclosed, they really listened to their customers and improved on the design. This area must be absolutely amazing in a cruise to the Caribbean.

 

I just think that they should adjust the hours of the gelato store/Carlo's bakery, and maybe add some lounges for people to sit and read.

 

 

 

I honestly think both areas are useless to me, but doesn't mean that I don't appreciate them for what they are. The Allure has that beautiful Central park surrounded by great restaurants, but it lacks that connection with the ocean. While X has that connection with the ocean but again the grass just have no point for me. One thing that puzzled me why don't they have a different setup and had the cabanas facing towards the ocean to make them more private and with a better view.

 

 

 

Service

 

RCCL : 4.5

X : 4.5

NCL :2.5

 

Here is where NCL is way behind. I should not have been addressed the way I was in this cruise. They really need a lot of improvement in this area.

 

The overall feel of the ship was not the same as the Allure where the crew just felt proud of their vessel. There was a feeling of disconnection of the staff with the ship.

 

The only reason I am not scoring Breakaway lower was because of our fantastic stewardess, and a few great servers in the Bistro, Teppa and Raw Bar. But overall I think this is where NCL falls behind RCCL and X. They really need improvement in this area.

 

 

 

Both ships shinned in this sector, while X did not have Gilbert, they were still a solid team and one that I was very glad to have.

 

Other than the night at Tuscan the waiters were all spectacular (Like I said he was not bad, just a little slow for our taste) and in the Allure all our waiters were great with the exception of the night 150 when we felt like we were second class. I was very glad that our servers in Murano were not like the one in 150, they were actually so nice and friendly.

 

 

Total count

 

RCCL 45.5

X 41.7

NCL 43.1

 

Just like I thought. The funny thing is that I swear to you, I did not adjust these numbers. It is just how it came up as I was adding the scores.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Conclusion

 

 

 

Ok let’s see… so as you can see Breakaway scored in second place, and that is exactly how I feel. NCL has an incredible product and one that delivers. I absolutely loved Breakaway, and I cannot tell you how excited I am to get Getaway here in Miami next year!

 

Everything about the ship is just stunning; I was very much impressed by it. And all those worries that I had prior boarding started to disappear as I saw how the ship actually worked. I was very worried about the ship feeling overly crowded, and that I would not be able to use the jacuzzis, ect. I am not sure how, but NCL did just as good as a job as RCCL did with distributing the crowds throughout the ship.

 

NCL is by far the line that nickled and dimed the most out of any line that I have been on. Not only that, but they seemed to be in a process of adjusting prices and everything seemed to go up in our cruise in particular. I am not a fan of this, but then again, you don't have to purchase anything if you don't want to. It is all about choices… and NCL gives you lots of them.

 

My huge problem with NCL was their Guest Relations service. That put such a dent on the cruise that it simply could not compete against the Allure. I would not have been treated that way in the Allure. The service, as I said, also lacks, but hopefully that will be improved upon with time.

 

The energy that this ship radiates is crazy, and not only that but the amount of activities offered is just about enough to keep everyone entertained. They do a great job at it! My guess is that Julie is the one in charge of this. And like I said, Julie does one amazing job. Great job Julie! Maybe next time we can actually have a better encounter =).

 

I had a great time in this cruise, and I would dare say that I had possibly more fun in this cruise that in the Allure. But encompassing the entire experience, this cruise just falls slightly behind.

 

 

 

I am sure you noticed that the Allure might of won if you go by score factor and I think that I still have the Allure as my favorite ship ever, I actually think it will be quite hard to get down from his throne. There is just so much to do in that ship that it is hard not to fall in love with it.

 

That said, we loved the Silhouette and had a grand time. Sure the weather could of been better and our neighbors were not the best, but we still had an excellent vacation.

 

I will certainly consider X for a future cruise, I think that it would be an ideal ship to cruise say Europe or Alaska. I could totally see myself traveling around Europe on this incredible ship.

 

Will I do it again in the near future? I don't think so, I get bored easily and once I've seen it I want to do something new, the same goes for the Allure. Right after my NCL Breakaway cruise, I will be interested in trying the Carnival Breeze, Royal Princess and Quantum of the Seas. We will see if I am lucky enough to do all 3.

 

 

 

 

Thank you!

 

I want to thank all of you for being a part of this. Reviews as such would be nothing without my followers. The more reviews I do, the more I realize how much work it takes to do them. Right now I am exhausted and I can't wait to fully relax again on a day off. I plan on reviewing the Breeze in August, but I think I am going to tackle that cruise differently. I will take advantage that Sarah is doing most of the planning, and just go and relax. Sorry Sarah, I am just beat right now. I need a cruise were I have little in the works of planning :D.

 

 

 

Once again, thank you all very much for following our adventure, I truly appreciate it! Getting to almost 200k views in weeks is not easy, and that is all thanks to everyone in here.

 

 

 

 

 

A special thank you to Sarah for editing this last section, I am beat and really could not do it.

 

 

And also to pcreek for sending me that amazing Breakaway Coin. Thank you. I have a full collection now =)

 

 

 

 

Also special thanks to my FB friend who invited me to Starbucks =), yum yum. I rather not type the name of the person for privacy.

 

 

 

 

 

Until next time ;-)…

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Man, you are unbelievable. Reading your review is almost cruising with you. I will be taking Breakaway to Bermuda in September. It is my first time on Breakaway and to Bermuda. But it seems I am going back for the second round after reading this thread. It is long (very long) but worth every minute of it. You rock

[Stillfloatin']

Ok, ok, I'm crying uncle and booking the breakaway. Gambee, you should get the commission. I wasn't even considering this cruise before your review. And now, ive already got two other couples booking with me. good freakin' review!

[zales]

LOVE LOVE LOVED YOUR REVIEW. ALSO THANK YOU FOR POSTING THE RESTRICTIONS FOR THE SLIDES. I WAS GOING TO BRING MY SON ON THE CRUISE FOR THAT MAIN REASON BUT HE'S ONLY 55LBS:eek: I KNOW NOT EVEN CLOSE:rolleyes:

 

SPECIAL THANKS TO WEDNESDAY FOR TELLING ME THAT GAMBEE'S REVIEW WAS IN THE NCL SECTION. I COULD HAVE MISSED SUCH A WONDERFUL REVIEW:( BUT I DIDN'T:D

[swim13]

THANK YOU GAMBEE!

 

I can't believe the journey on Breakaway is over! :( I am so glad I found your reviews way back during the Allure, you are the one who has inspired me to do a review on Allure in 20 days, mostly dedicated to you! :) Are we still planning on me getting you the Allure model?! And what the heck, I just get Lightroom 4 and now they announce Lightroom 5 is coming soon!! :mad: I guess thats why I was able to buy it at a $50 discount! :p

 

I guess that now that we know which is still your favorite ship, I can complete the TEAM GAMBEE shirt! I totally knew it would be Allure! :D

[smeck]

Fantastic job as usual. I can only imagine the amount of work went into it. We all appreciate it!!

[Guest debbiejohncruise]

Amazing review, thank you!!

 

Interesting to note that if you'd reviewed your own cabin and had the service that NCL is known for, it would have beaten Allure.

 

I don't think I'm heading back to RCi anytime soon, but knowing how much you loved Allure, that says a lot for Breakaway.

 

Thanks again!

 

We are going with NCL for the first time in Sept on the Breakaway. We haven't cruised with RCI yet and we are wanting to cruise for 21 days in Feb and are leaning towards Holland America. Since you have cruised with NCL and RCI - what are the pros and cons for both??? Thanks.:)

[MAZ100]

Great Job.. Gambee

 

Thank you for posting the raw bar menu..

 

Also I have a question

 

What type of food they serve at the BREEZEAWAY BAR & GRILL.

Is it the same Garden café menu's as the other NCL cruise?

Also I hear they serve food at Spice H2O

What type of food do they serve?

Did you happen to take pictures from those 2 places?

thanks and appreciate all the pictures

[rstout]

Delete

Edited June 11, 2013 by rstout

[Guest debbiejohncruise]

Man, you are unbelievable. Reading your review is almost cruising with you. I will be taking Breakaway to Bermuda in September. It is my first time on Breakaway and to Bermuda. But it seems I am going back for the second round after reading this thread. It is long (very long) but worth every minute of it. You rock

 

We tried to get to Bermuda a few years ago with Holland America and weather prevented us from getting there so we are also going with Breakaway in Sept to Bermuda. If weather doesn't permit us getting there, we will have to fly there sometime. lol

I really enjoyed reading that gentleman's reviews of Celebrity, RCCL and NCL as we have travelled with Celebrity in Europe but never on RCCL and NCL. It will be our first cruise with NCL and looking forward to it!!!:)

[riclop]

Amazing review, thank you!!

 

Interesting to note that if you'd reviewed your own cabin and had the service that NCL is known for, it would have beaten Allure.

 

I don't think I'm heading back to RCi anytime soon, but knowing how much you loved Allure, that says a lot for Breakaway.

 

Thanks again!

Not in your wildest dreams will breakaway beat Allure, in any category.

[WanderlustingDiva]

Great job ... Great review Gambee!!! I have enjoyed reading from page one til the end!! Thank you for taking time out of your schedule to do it !! I look forward to the rest of your reviews!!!

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

[shoreless]

Thank you Gambee. Wonderful review, awesome pictures, and amazing video tour! The Waterfront looks great, even in the rain.

 

Thanks to you and Slice I have a long list of things not to be missed. :) And thanks to poor Joeski's review I also have a short list of what to watch out for. :eek:

[big al]

Gambee- Loved your final thoughts & comparison...a tiny bit surprised about X because everyone ( including CC here..) raves about all the new Solstice class ships...I have never been on one, yet- did the Mercury years ago...loved Oasis & Allure like you...Question:you mentioned in the Allure review that English was your second language..I thought you did an outstanding job writing & communicating your thoughts & opinions. I will look forward to seeing your reviews on the Breeze, new Princess ( I may do,too..), and Quantum as well.. May I ask what is your primary language? I ask because I am born in Casablanca, raised in NY, live here 45 minutes from you (North)...my wife is from Peru, and my father was Italian..so we spoke English, Spanish, French ( from Morocco), Italian, and Arabic daily in my house...is Spanish your 1st language? If you don't want to say, that's Ok, I understand...but after reading all your posts, I'm just curious! Thanks, gracias,grazie, merci,and can't remember in Arabic...

 

Big Al

[Tom-n-Cheryl]

Not in your wildest dreams will breakaway beat Allure, in any category.

 

In "variety of food options" I'm thinking it would... though I could go for a Park Cafe roast beef sandwich right about now! :D

 

Pertaining to those in suites: Being familiar with the butler service on NCL (which RCI does not provide) I'd say that stateroom service would be superior. Having the dedicated (fee included) restaurant in the Haven... hard to beat that.

 

Tom

[hpecorari]

I also would like to thank Gambee, Slifeoflife, and all others who have done a great job doing a review of the Breakaway. I love to cruise....but I'm not sure what I love more......the anticipation or the cruise itself! Okay.....maybe the cruise itself but the anticipation is a HUGE part of my vacation/cruise.....

and this truly did the trick! Can't wait!!!! So thank you!