I enjoyed it. I thought they did a good job of addressing lots of the concerns raised on this forum.
I'm not too worried about the lack of butler service in November in my sky suite as haven't used them much before and I am happy they've added Coco Cay. I tried once with Celebrity years ago and the wind didn't work out. I have been on 2 Royal Caribbean cruises just to get to Coco Cay.
But team dog, shouldn't have answered that way!