We did Indy twice before and have a cruise booked on her in 2025. Great ship and crew!
As for reviews, I approach it this way.
1) I look for the consensus comments (good or bad), the more specific the better. The consensus or trend has to be from a number of reviews on different recent sailings. I never listen to a single cruiser - some just have an axe to grind. Highly subjective general comments on things like food are not anything I pay much attention to.
2) As a long-time member and poster here on CC, I sometimes give more weight to comments from members who I "know" from this board and have previously respected their opinions. In fact some I have actually met on cruises.
3) no need to listen to me!