Decisions, Decisions, Decisions......
We know where you are coming from.
We are also challenged with PG but fell in love this past sailing. But enjoyed BC several times in the past. But PG is the future bookings..
Not really QG though we were on the QE2 but in these days of cuisine, not attracted to the Menus. As DW said, If not attracted to choices, we can downgrade requests to PG style.
QE2 QG much different with availability of these days products.
We did granted appreciate the extra space in PG but QG would be too much. We don't entertain. So PG just right.
We also don't like the closeness in QG. Tables to close as PG more spread out.
But try this and see. But if you would like QG experience but less, PG way to go. After BC which is nice, you will see PG to be the midpoint to satisfy.
This is my honest opinion.
But enjoy!