I booked it for day 6, not that many choices. I'm ok with lobster roll so I'm going no matter what. Day 2 or 3 is cheers with a officer. I'm D+ not pinnacle and we got moved to the other day when too many pinnacles onboard so that's why I picked day 6. Its only offered those 3 days. For about $20 of obc, it's still worth it to me on free money. I got a little from my TA, and a teensy bit more from next cruise and another $100 for stock and solo so I get to spend it all. I got it a week ago 15% off so about $20 with tips. Doesn't seem that bad to me. I like fried fish or lobster however they cook it. And the appetizers. I've read a few who were disappointed but dont know why.