Sorry, the rule is: You may send a steak back once. But, if you send it back a second time, prepare to receive a steak with footprints or other foreign matter.
Side note: while at a Captain’s table on Celebrity an attendee decided to send back his steak, twice. This didn’t sit well with the Captain. He called the rest of the attendees to a special lunch leaving out the offender. And mentioning the issue a couple times during the lunch.